|
About the Academy
Awards
Basser Library
Education
Events
Fellowship
International
Media releases
National Committees
Nobel Australians
Policy
Reports and submissions
Publications
The Shine Dome
|
Home > About the Academy > Biographical memoirs
BIOGRAPHICAL MEMOIRS
Raymond James Wood Le Fèvre 1905-1986
By M.J. Aroney and A.D. Buckingham
This memoir was originally published in Historical Records of Australian Science, vol.7, no.3, 1988.
Numbers in brackets refer to the notes at the end of the text.
Introduction
Raymond James Wood Le Fèvre was born in North London on the first day of April, 1905. He was
the eldest of three children of Raymond James Le Fèvre,
the managing clerk of a firm of London solicitors, and his wife
Ethel May (née Wood). Of his four grandparents, three had
died before 1910. Only his father's mother, née Louise
Darby, of Bath survived into his childhood. She was a strict,
severe and religious person, always dressed in black as was then
customary for widows. She, with her watch-maker husband, had,
many years before, established a home in Richmond, Surrey, and
there produced six children of whom Le Fèvre's father was
the youngest boy. Her family practically formed the local church
choir of St Elizabeth's Roman Catholic Church at Richmond. At
eight years of age, Le Fèvre became an altar boy and he
remained in close association with this church, eventually becoming
the Master of Ceremonies in his 20s. Further, through his close
friendship with many of the clergy, he found great interest in
church and choral music, history, ritual and church vestments. This aspect of his education and life over the years ran in
parallel with his secular life.
Le Fèvre's parents moved to St Margaret's, East Twickenham,
in Middlesex, a district just across the Thames from Richmond.
His schooling began in the infants' class of Gumley House Convent,
Isleworth, and after about a year he was transferred to St James
School, Twickenham, an elementary school staffed by Sisters of
Mercy and lay teachers. About April 1915, he was transferred to
the Salesian school at Farnborough, Hants, a boarding school which
Le Fèvre has recorded as being 'austere though probably
healthy'. Cricket and football were played but he showed no great
aptitude for either. He was, however, a good swimmer; his family
kept a punt on the Thames. He enjoyed visits to Farnborough Abbey
and roaming relatively freely on Farnborough Common. The Abbey
had been founded by the Empress Eugenie to house the tombs of
the Emperor Napoleon III and his son the Prince Imperial, who
had been killed by an assagai while fighting in Zululand in 1879,
in the Crypt Chapel, which to the young Le Fèvre had a
fascination as a sombre and mysterious place an impression intensified
by distant chanting from the church above.
In 1915 Farnborough Common was still open to the public. For small
boys part of its attraction was a large pond in which on warm
days they could swim, but a larger part arose from the use of
the Common as an aerodrome for the adjoining Government Aircraft
Factory that was then growing up around the old balloon and airship
establishment. Here could be seen pusher-engined Farman biplanes,
B.E.2c's, and other fragile-looking contraptions staggering shakily
into or out of the air. Le Fèvre could not have known at
the time that the G.A.F. had just gathered together a group of
able men, mostly from Cambridge, destined to become leaders in
various branches of pure and applied science men such as F.A.
Lindemann (later Lord Cherwell), B.M. Jones (later Sir Melville
Jones), G.I. Taylor (later Sir Geoffrey Taylor), G.P. Thomson
(later Sir George Thomson and a Nobel Laureate in physics), W.S.
Farren (later Sir William Farren, Director of the Royal Aircraft
Establishment during the Second World War), G.T.R. Hill (designer
of the 'Pterodactyl' aeroplane), F.W. Aston (subsequently a Nobel
Prize winner in chemistry), and Hermann Glauert (whose contributions
to aerodynamical design, to aerofoil theory, to the analysis of
auto-gyro flight, and so on, were to earn him election to the
Royal Society of London in 1931; at the height of his powers he
was unfortunately killed by a falling tree on the Common in mid-1934).
In the course of his career, Le Fèvre was destined to have
an official place in the Establishment which grew out of 'the
muddle of huge shanties' that were there in his school days.
Educationally the Salesians were 'earnest and mostly encouraging';
their curriculum and methods were conventional. Latin, algebra,
geometry and French were taught among other subjects and particular
emphasis was given to religious knowledge and the catechism. In
1916 Le Fèvre's parents decided that he should live at
home, so in the Spring of that year he was enrolled in the Isleworth
County School in Middlesex. The ICS, although founded formally
only in 1895, could trace its ancestry back to a Stuart Charity
School founded ca. 1630. From 1715-1813 this became known
as the Isleworth Charity School where, as recounted in later years
by Le Fèvre, '40 boys and 20 girls were clothed and taught
reverence for Protestant and Hanoverian authority, given principles
but not opinions, and generally taught to be submissive, pious,
industrious, and respectful citizens'. The school evolved into
a nineteenth-century National School and an Upper Department was
established that later merged into a new grammar school being
formed by the British and Foreign School Society. Le Fèvre
attended this school from 1916 to 1923, recalling that 'The atmosphere
in all senses was pleasant literally because we were often downwind
either of Pears' soap works or Watney's Brewery, and figuratively
because our small numbers made friendships with one another, and
contacts with the staff, easier and freer than would have been
the case in a larger establishment.'
Because of the war, a number of masters were in the services,
their places being temporarily filled by women. One of the latter,
Miss E.B. Murdoch, conveyed to Le Fèvre his first impressions
of chemistry. She believed in practical experience as a
method of learning; her introductory experiment was the examination
of a mixture of iron filings and flowers of sulphur before and
after heating. The vivid light emission accompanying combination
and the altered behaviour towards a magnet underlined indelibly
the differences between physical and chemical changes. From that
moment, chemistry displaced history as Le Fèvre's favourite
subject. Conversion was completed during the next annual session
when physics and chemistry were taught by B.H. Walmsley, 'the
finest teacher in all my pre-University experience'. Notable among
his school activities were a strong interest in historical novels
(graduating from Henty to Scott), photography (winning a competition
in Isleworth for two enlargements, done with a home-made lantern,
of architectural subjects at Verulamium and St Albans Cathedral),
rifle shooting (twice winning the school championship), and listening
to music both liturgical and orchestral.
With the passing of the matriculation examination, the question
of a future career became important. His father would have liked
him to study law but this prospect did not appeal as much as a
livelihood involving science and preferably chemistry. It was
B.H. Walmsley who convinced his parents that this was not a disastrous
course and that it was essential that he should arm himself with
a degree and, if possible, get some experience of research before
being launched on to the labour market. He therefore went into
the post-matriculation science stream with the object of taking
the London Intermediate BSc examination during the two years
of the sixth form. Four subjects were required by the regulations.
He chose pure and applied mathematics, physics and chemistry.
The Headmaster, W.T. Kenwood, a believer in general education,
discipline, and the idea that improvement of boys came best from
hard work, personally took the combined science and arts groups
for four periods a week, using a procedure that could be termed
'seminar leading', in which one student would read some passage
or other and the rest would discuss it. The students learned a
lot in this way, for example, selected passages from the Old Testament
easily led to 'facts of life'; Ruskin's Stones of Venice started
talk about architecture, travel, painting, mosaics and the like;
an elementary book on economics likewise gave some insight into
the production, distribution and consumption of wealth, and probably
reinforced the determination of many to make a university, rather
than commerce, their goal. Although a martinet who inspired fear
in many boys and who closely and severely supervised the staff,
Kenwood insisted that the sixth-form timetables included some
half-dozen hours each week for private study, on their own without
any masters being present excellent training for the self-learning
later to be undertaken in the post-school years.
Walmsley took the class for physics and chemistry. His enthusiasm
in the laboratory was genuine and infectious. He was always fair
and just, never sarcastic or sharp-tongued. They worked extensively
from J.W. Mellor's Modern Inorganic Chemistry, E. Edser's
General Physics and Light, H.E. Hadley's Magnetism
and Electricity and others of similar standard. His introduction
to organic chemistry followed the plan upon which E.L. Lewis's
Elements of Organic Chemistry was based; this was essentially
practical. In the very first lesson they learnt about fermentation,
brewing, enzymes, wines, and so forth, and made up an aqueous
solution of glucose to which yeast was added. A few days later
the mixture was distilled and the easy accessibility of alcohol
made obvious. Its value as a raw material was then illustrated
by preparing, from fresh alcohol, such compounds as ether, ethylene,
acetaldehyde, ethyl acetate and acetamide. In this way they were
introduced to the idea that organic chemistry dealt with families
of inter-related and interconvertible molecules; moreover, they
were acquiring enough personal experience to be able to appreciate
the simplifying and systematising advantages of Kekulé's structure
theory which, sixty years earlier, had brought logic and harmony
into what might easily have become a vast catalogue of uncoordinated
empirical facts. Opportunities were given also to try their hands
at many of the reactions and procedures described by J.B. Cohen
in the 1918 reprint of his Practical Organic Chemistry, an
outstandingly popular book.
In 1922 Le Fèvre sat for the London Intermediate BSc
and Higher School Certificates. The examinations were passed at
a level sufficient to qualify him for a Middlesex Senior County
Scholarship worth about £25 per annum, a sum that just covered
the fees at East London College (now Queen Mary College). Application
was made to this institution and admission granted after various
interviews. In September 1922, therefore, he found himself an
undergraduate looking towards a BSc degree of the University
of London.
East London College
In 1922, East London College was young in years. It stood on a
site originally provided by the Drapers' Company in 1887, and
seemed to have grown around the People's Palace and other buildings
that had once housed a technical school and facilities for popular
entertainment. The College thus found itself the possessor of
premises that included a large hall containing a pipe organ; nevertheless
the area was architecturally very ordinary. During 1907, E.L.C.
was recognised by the University of London as a School in the
Faculties of Arts, Science, and Engineering. Chemistry established
itself under the influence of Professor J.T. Hewitt, a student
of Victor Meyer and a man whose standards and interests had been
influenced by membership of St John's College, Cambridge and periods
spent in the Universities of Berlin and Heidelberg. The research
climate around Hewitt was immensely stimulating and favoured all
branches of chemistry (1).
Chemists who benefited from such guidance included Sir J.C. Drummond
(later professor of biochemistry, University College London),
G.M. Bennett (later a professor at Sheffield, then at King's College
London, and finally the Government Chemist), and E.E. Turner (of
whom more later). Others in Hewitt's circle, either as staff colleagues
or research collaborators, were F.G. Pope, A.D. Mitchell and J.J.
Fox (later knighted, and in 1936 appointed to be Government Chemist).
Fox had contacts with early pioneers of physical methods for the
investigation of chemical problems and among his publications
were some dealing with topics in the formative days of infrared
spectroscopy.
In time, Le Fèvre was ushered into the presence of Professor
J.R. Partington by S.K Tweedy, J.R.P.'s hard-working personal
assistant. He was a little disappointed to find, not a bearded
and reverend-looking professor his ideas having been formed
by pictures of Mendeleef but instead a pink-faced, somewhat
testy individual who expressed dissatisfaction at the extent of
his mathematical experiences. He was given an extended booklist
with many of the standard chemical texts of the time and including
several items by Partington himself it involved a not inconsiderable
financial outlay.
In the laboratory, Le Fèvre worked among a group of friends
that was to keep together for three or four years until the ends
of their periods as research students. Among these were N. Hadley,
H.F. Halliwell, M.A. Mayes, F.G. Soper, E.B. Evans, A. Brewin,
H.C. Gull, D.D. Moir and T.B. Child. A.I. Vogel was a year senior
to Le Fèvre and a research student, working with J.R. Partington
on sulphur sesquioxide. Le Fèvre has put on record some
of his impressions:
As a candidate for chemistry honours, with physics a subsidiary
subject, I attended lectures by a range of staff: Partington on
inorganic and historical chemistry (although J.R.P.'s vocal style
was not exciting, it was redeemed by the fact that he, plus Farrow
his lecture assistant, performed in front of the class most of
the experiments and demonstrations described in Partington's 'Text
Book of Inorganic Chemistry'); E.E. Turner on organic chemistry
(Turner was always clear and precise, he wrote rapidly and neatly
on the blackboard, and often carried out small-scale preparations,
crystallisations, or distillations, to illustrate whatever was
under discussion, E.E.T. showed more than anyone else I encountered
during my student years, what could be done with the simplest
apparatus used with understanding and experience). W.H. Paterson
and D.C. Jones took us for physical chemistry, which in those
days was almost non-instrumented, reasonably practical, and not
highly mathematical. To me the most troublesome course was thermodynamics,
the material of which seemed 'dry' in the extreme, especially
when droned out by J.R.P. more-or-less verbatim from his book.
For eloquence, I think that Dr Alan Ferguson, of the Department
of Physics, talking on the properties of matter, surpassed all
others we heard as undergraduates; to Ferguson I owe my especial
interest in 'additive properties' an interest which has persisted
for 60 or more years. For enthusiasm, I rank E.E.T. above all
others. He occupied a small room at one end of the large laboratory
where we 2nd and 3rd year students were located. I was on the
second bench from the door of his room from which he would often
emerge and chat with whomsoever he encountered. E.E.T. had not
long before returned from two years as a lecturer in the University
of Sydney, where he had collaborated with G.J. Burrows in examining
the optical resolvability of certain inorganic complexes having
Fe, Al, As or Sb as central atoms. At E.L.C. he was continuing
this programme, making alkaloidal ferrioxalates, aluminoxalates,
and antimonoxalates, etc. I well remember being invited to admire
a beautifully crystallised strychnine aluminoxalate spread out
to dry. Through his ever-open door we could see that he worked
constantly. Later on, I had many opportunities to admire Turner's
general skills in the laboratory, at glass-blowing (he said he
had been taught by his brother, a student under Ramsay at University
College) and in all phases of preparative technique, an aspect
of chemistry for which Turner had genuine enthusiasm.
Le Fèvre's interests extended well beyond his science studies.
He availed himself fully of the range of cultural activities so
readily accessible in London theatres, museums, cathedrals and
churches with outstanding choirs, cinemas, historic buildings.
In June 1925, he passed his final examinations with First Class
Honours in Chemistry and at once began research with E.E. Turner.
On the BSc results he was awarded a DSIR Scholarship of
£140 a year. His initial effort in research was inauspicious,
involving as it did a too vigorous reaction and subsequent fire,
but despite Le Fèvre's apprehensions, most people laughed
off the incident. He began a study of the orientations of substituents
entering diphenyl compounds. This led him to investigate the general
usefulness of piperidine when used as an agent in locating halogen
atoms situated ortho or para to nitro groups in
aromatics. The results consistently supported the view that piperidine
was of great value as an agent. This work was summarised in his
thesis for the MSc degree, awarded in 1927; it also formed part
of one of the first papers published with Turner. The scission
of diphenyl ethers by piperidine was also examined.
The major preoccupation of Le Fèvre and Turner at this
time was with questions concerning the stereochemistry of diphenyl
and its derivatives. Chemists were beginning to query the space
formula proposed by Kaufler. Reinvestigations showed much of his
evidence to be dependent on errors and mistakes. From the confusion,
a simpler picture gradually developed. Le Fèvre and Turner
were led to conclude that an unsubstituted diphenyl molecule will
tend to be planar unless it is prevented by steric or other forces,
in which case the structure as a whole would adopt the shape of
a two-bladed propeller and become capable of optical resolution
into dextro and laevo forms. This recognition of
conformational isomerism in the aromatic series opened the way
for developmental work in several laboratories in England and
elsewhere.
University College London
In 1928, Le Fèvre became a lecturer in organic chemistry
at University College London. His departmental duties were not
numerous. Mainly these were to demonstrate in the organic laboratory
under the direction of O.L. Brady and to help on Saturday mornings
with the elementary chemistry classes for engineers that were
being run by R.W. Lunt. His immediate research programme was concerned
with finishing his PhD work; the thesis (QMC thesis 82) submitted
that year incorporated material from a number of published papers.
The nitration of 4,4'-difluorodiphenyl was to be his last contact
with this type of work on the diphenyl series, although Turner
and his colleagues continued with these compounds very productively
for thirty or more years.
At University College, changes were occurring. Professor J.N.
Collie retired in 1928 and was replaced by Robert Robinson (later
Sir Robert) who was then entering one of his most active periods
of research. Robinson had already established a brilliant reputation
for his contributions to many separate regions of organic chemistry,
notably to electronic theories of reactivity and structure and
to knowledge of plant pigments, drugs, alkaloids and so on. Robinson
rapidly built up a large following of research students, some
coming with him to London from Manchester, others travelling from
countries overseas. Thus in a short time the UCL Department
of Organic Chemistry became very cosmopolitan and stimulating
to its members in ways not always experienced in other university
departments. The traditions of friendliness were fostered by daily
meetings for tea, coffee and much informal conversation, and the
fact that staff and postgraduate students behaved as near equals.
Years before, a 'Seven Seas Club' had been established for research
students who had travelled to London via one of the seven seas
or who had been at UCL for more than three years; all this
helped to create a happy and united social atmosphere.
Robinson was not a remote or distant departmental head but one
always accessible to colleagues and students, as he usually worked
in his private laboratory with its doors constantly open. His
wife, Dr Gertrude Maude Robinson, joined him very frequently,
thus adding her personal interests in plant pigments and her quiet
and dignified charm to the other attractive qualities of the Department.
Le Fèvre's lectures have been described by Professor H.J.A.
Dartnall as follows:
I was a Chemistry student at University College between the
years 1931-34 and attended his lectures on Organic Chemistry.
The theatre was always filled to overflowing, for his lectures
were marvellously planned and were not only full of examination
'meat' from the student's point of view but full of interest too.
Nearly all the statements he made were illustrated by experiments,
which were carried out with breakneck speed, yet he would write
the equations on the black-board very slowly so that we could
get them all down in our note books. He was always immaculately
groomed and attired (like most lecturers then) in morning dress.
I suspect he was a little vain, but with good reason for he had
a commanding presence and was very handsome. His entrance into
the Lecture Theatre was always accompanied by stamping of feet
(a sign of approval).
His interests to use his own phrase 'ranged from the sacramental
to the excremental'! On one occasion he was well ahead of his
syllabus and therefore treated us to a fascinating and learned
discourse on the famous burial shroud of Christ at Turin, with
a chemical interpretation of the mysterious markings on the shroud.
Le Fèvre became actively involved with questions concerning
the orientations of groups entering aromatic structures a hotly
argued topic at the time. The orienting ability of oxonium oxygen
was examined experimentally as oxygen was the last element requiring
investigation in this connection in the 'onium' state. In discussion,
Robinson had suggested that the phenylpyrylium salts might be
looked at 'since it should be easy to get a positive oxonium pole
conveniently situated to orient substitutions in that series'.
From substitution experiments mainly upon derivatives of 2-phenylbenzopyrylium
perchlorate, Le Fèvre was able to conclude that the positively
charged oxonium pole forms one of the strongest meta-directive
influences known. Another study was concerned with the variable
electropolar properties of the nitroso-group. In aromatic systems
the strongly activating effect of the nitroso-group on halogens
situated in the ortho- or para-positions was noted
and compared with the similar action of the nitro-group in analogous
circumstances. The nitroso-group was behaving as a meta-directing
group yet experiment showed that nitrosobenzene could be directly
substituted by bromine to give 4-bromonitrosobenzene. The apparently
anomalous character of the nitroso-radical in nitrosobenzene on
substitution by electrophilic reagents was investigated and rationalized
in terms of Robinson's mechanistic concepts. Supportive evidence
was provided from dipole moment measurements of derivatives of
nitrosobenzene. Other work of that period included studies of
the dinitration of 1-phenylpiperidine from which it was concluded
that the piperidine radical possesses an abnormally strong para-directing
influence.
During 1932-34, a number of cases of orientation by alkyl groups
were investigated where the results appeared to follow the steric
rather than the electropolar nature of the subsitutents. In this
connection the nitration, chlorination, bromination, iodination
and sulphonation of p-cymene were investigated quantitatively.
In parallel, polarisation and polarisability effects in aromatic
hydro-carbons were examined by dipole moment measurements on p-ethyltoluene,
p-cymene, p-tert-butyl toluene, etc, and some halogeno-
and nitro-derivatives.
In 1931-32 the interaction of aqueous ammonium sulphide with formalin,
begun in 1928 with a study of the period of induction, was carried
a stage further by the isolation of the chief product in a pure
state, thus enabling its constitution to be determined. Other
work included colligative-property studies of solid terpenes.
These last two projects were to assume a special significance
for Le Fèvre since they introduced to research a Miss Catherine
Gunn Tideman who earlier had been a student in his practical chemistry
classes. To quote Le Fèvre:
Among those taking organic chemistry during 1928-29 was one
who seemed always cheerful, lively, ready with relevant comments
on current or local affairs, full of conversational topics, of
repartee, energy and vigour; a hockey player of enthusiasm (who
had once knocked unconscious an opponent through an accidental
head-to-head collision), a tireless dancer, a rider of horses
(her grandmother had owned a riding school in Glasgow), not excessively
teetotal but convivial with most of the women and men contemporary
with her at UCL. She and I chatted in the lab. about many things
not always scientific. She lived in Lambeth where she 'housekept'
for her two brothers and knew all about the Old Vic to which later
on, she and I went fairly frequently. She was then C.G. Tideman,
later Mrs. Catherine G. Le Fèvre.
The marriage took place in Glasgow on 1 August 1931. They rented
a house at Neasden, about twenty minutes by car from University
College. Catherine Le Fèvre was to become her husband's
most constant and most valued research colleague. Their subsequent
work in physical organic chemistry was strongly encouraged by
Professor C.K. (later Sir Christopher) Ingold who in 1930 had
taken up a Chair of Chemistry at University College in succession
to Robinson who had been elected to the Waynflete Chair of Chemistry
at Oxford.
From 1933 Le Fèvre became increasingly interested in the
applications of dipole moments to chemical problems. He had been
introduced to the technique by J.W. Smith with whom he had collaborated
in measuring the dielectric polarizations of nitroso-compounds
and of quinoline and isoquinoline, and from whom he later inherited
the apparatus when Smith left University College. Consequently,
the structures of numerous other substances were examined by this
method. An account of such structural studies as well as the use
of polarisation measurements to probe inductive and mesomeric
effects in molecules, is given in Le Fèvre's book, Dipole
Moments, Their Measurement and Application in Chemistry (Methuen,
London), which was first published in 1938. Problems of solute
association and aggregation were also explored. A number of papers
were published on the variation of molecular polarisation with
the permittivity of the solvent and, as well, with changes of
state. An equation connecting the true dipole moment of a gas
with the apparent moment in solution was advanced and led to the
starting of experimental work on the dipole moments in the vapour
state of a number of compounds with negative Kerr constants. Referring
to the English period of Le Fèvre's researches, Ingold
was later to write:
He had become well known as a physical organic chemist of great
power and originality. With several others in England he had cleared
up a morass of confusion concerning optical activity which, in
fact, arose from unrecognised confirmational causes. He had largely
alone, made several important contributions on the distinctive
roles of polarisation and polarisability in polarity. Dipole moments
were a much-used tool: using it he showed quantitatively how polarity
could be inverted by conjugation.
In March 1935, Le Fèvre was awarded the DSc degree; he
was promoted to Reader in 1938. In that year also their son, Ian,
was born. Soon after, Catherine was employed as a demonstrator
at University College and she also taught chemistry at Queen's
College, Harley Street.
About this time the Le Fèvres decided to set up apparatus
for the measurement of the Kerr effect, i.e. electrically induced
double refraction. In this they were encouraged by H.A. Stuart
of the Universität Mainz and G. Szivessy of the Universität Bonn,
and were helped by a grant from the Royal Society. By 1939, measurements
on gases and on organic substances in solution were being undertaken.
Other topics under investigation at the time included: the stereochemistry
of l,2-diketones, the geometrical isomerism of diazo-, azoxy-
and azo-compounds, the configurational relationships of certain
anils, the associations of aliphatic acids and of aromatic nitroso-compounds,
the dielectric polarizations of vapours, phototropy, and equilibria
of the keto-enol type. The outbreak of war caused the temporary
cessation of these activities. Prominent collaborators between
1928 and 1939 were C.G. Le Fèvre, J.W. Smith, J. Pearson,
P.J. Markham, S.N. Ganguly, P. Russell, E.D. Hughes, H. Vine,
V. de Gaouck, P.P. Hopf, G.S. Hartley, I. Dostrovsky and C.C.
Caldwell.
Le Fèvre's war work
During September 1939, University College granted Le Fèvre
temporary release and for a short time he was attached to the
Ministry of Home Security for the training of Gas Identification
Officers. About a dozen chemists were needed to help organise
and train the GIOs giving them 'practical experience of the
gases that might be encountered in time of war'. Special centres
of instruction were arranged in London and the provinces. Le Fèvre
was sent to one such centre at Battersea Polytechnic where he
worked as an instructor until well into December.
In the early days of January 1940, Le Fèvre joined the
Directorate of Scientific Research, Air Ministry (later the Ministry
of Aircraft Production). There he was an adviser to RAF Commands
on certain chemical aspects of armaments. He familiarised himself
with the techniques of manufacturing, handling, storage and charging
of toxic liquids and other materials. A careful watch was being
maintained at the time for evidence of the deliberate use by the
enemy of toxic chemicals for offensive purposes. Official apprehension
was fuelled by intelligence reports of vesicant stocks held by
the Germans, of records of mustard gas spraying by the Italians
in their Abyssinian campaign, and of analogous activities of French
and Spanish forces in North Africa. The Japanese had dropped gas
bombs at Changsha and it was thought they might behave similarly
if hostilities started in East Asia.
On 2 October 1940, a daughter, Nicolette, was born to the Le Fèvres
in London at a time when air-raids were beginning to become regular
nightly occurrences. Catherine and the children left soon after
to return to Harrogate where they had been living.
Early in 1941, it was decided that a supply of chemical weapons
should be sent to the RAF Command in Singapore and Le Fèvre
was to go there as a chemical adviser, with the honorary rank
of Wing Commander. He proceeded to Singapore through West Africa,
Egypt, India, Burma and Malaya. The fortnight he spent in Cairo
gave Le Fèvre the opportunity to see the arrangements made
by F.B. Kipping (from St John's College, Cambridge) for the reception
and storage of chemical stocks in the Middle East. In Singapore
he was met and briefed by Wing Commander Ramsay Rae (later to
become an Air Vice-Marshal), who was then the senior armament
officer of the RAF Far Eastern Command.
Le Fèvre's first duties concerned the extant plans for
anti-gas defence of all RAF areas and making arrangements for
the receipt, storage and handling of chemical weapons that were
expected to arrive in a few weeks' time. He found most buildings
on airforce stations to be 'fantastically insecure, being constructed
in tropical fashion of light-weight materials of various kinds...'.
While contemplating the storage of gas weapons, he chanced to
meet M.W.F. Tweedie, the Curator of the Raffles Museum, whose
archaeological and speleological interests had given him a good
knowledge of excavations and caves in Malaya. On Tweedie's advice,
the Batu caves just outside Kuala Lumpur were examined. Those
that were suitable were cleared of the bat dung that had lain
undisturbed for years by offering it to the Malay inhabitants
who gladly took it, regarding it as first-class fertiliser. Within
a week, the first of the gas storage depots in Malaya was started,
and soon stocked by train from Singapore.
The RAF Far Eastern Command had hurriedly constructed landing
grounds at intervals along the Burma road, so Le Fèvre
was sent to visit them, up as far as Lashio near the China-Burma
frontier. Of special interest was a stop at Toungoo where Colonel
Chennault and his Flying Tigers were based. They seemed knowledgeable
about Japanese tactics and equipment, but when asked about earlier
reports of chemical warfare activity in China they appeared genuinely
ignorant.
On his return to Singapore, Le Fèvre was given instructions
from London that he was to try to travel into China as a university
lecturer, a civilian, suitably clothed at Air Force expense. He
was to go to Changsha or wherever Japanese chemical weapons (or
casualties therefrom) had been reported and to try to arrange
that a few unexploded bombs, and other chemical warfare samples,
be brought back to some place where analyses and examinations
could be performed. It was thought that Singapore, which had an
efficient Government Laboratory, would meet this requirement adequately.
However, intelligence reports began to come in that a Japanese
fleet was somewhere in the South China Sea and fears of an invasion
attempt on the Kra Isthmus or the Malayan coast were becoming
stronger and stronger. Le Fèvre's China trip was therefore
suspended pro tem; instead, a somewhat ancient specimen
of a Type 92 50-kg bomb was sent from (probably) the Air Attaché's
Office in Chungking. The liquid contents seemed to be a fairly
pure Lewisite/Mustard mixture, as already described in Japanese
weapon manuals available at the time.
Pearl Harbour had been bombed on 7 December and air raids on Singapore
were soon to be a regular occurrence. They were almost unopposed
since the defenders lacked aircraft capable of dealing with the
numbers and capabilities of the enemy. With the sinking of the
Prince of Wales and the Repulse on 10 December and
news of further Japanese successes it was thought advisable to
bring back to Singapore the Batu caves stocks. Ultimately it was
decided that the whole stock should be put into lighters and towed
to one of the numerous small islands near Singapore, where they
would be out of the way of operations but accessible if needed.
St John's East, a once-time leper settlement, proved suitable.
Seven lighters were loaded and towed by tugs; they were taken
to the island, run up the beach and secured.
However, the war situation was rapidly worsening and as part of
a general 'denial' scheme, Le Fèvre was ordered to plan
the destruction of 'gas' stocks. With time running out, the lighters
were taken out to sea and sunk. During the above operations, the
S.S. Silver Larch arrived in Singapore bringing chemical
and other cargo. It was re-routed to Oosthaven in south Sumatra.
About a week before the capitulation, Le Fèvre left Singapore
on a Yangtse river boat, the Whangpu, for Palembang, Sumatra,
and from there he went by train to Oosthaven. Still pursuing the
Silver Larch, he set out for Batavia on a 500-ton RAF
auxiliary, the Tung Song, and from there went to Tjilatjap
in south Java. A group of about 240, mostly RAF personnel,
was taken on board the Tung Song, believed at the time to
be the last friendly ship to leave Java before the Japanese occupation.
The hazardous journey to Exmouth Gulf in northwest Australia took
ten days or so. On 14 March 1942, they reached Fremantle. Thus,
by chance, Le Fèvre made his first contact with Australia.
An interchange of signals took place between OHQ RAAF Kingsway
and Air Force HQ Melbourne, and Le Fèvre found himself
temporarily seconded to the RAAF at a time when fears were
increasing of a Japanese invasion of Australia. He was given posts
in the Directorates of Armament and Air Staff Policy. He remained
in Australia nineteen months and travelled extensively about the
continent and allied-occupied New Guinea, arranging for the storage
and testing of mustard gas under tropical and semi-tropical conditions.
It was.recognised that the physiological effects could be quite
different from those known in Europe. Some of this work is described
in a contribution by Le Fèvre to the 1983 Australian Department
of Defence account, Mustard Gas Field Trials during World War
II, by R.G. Gillis (2). He
became a casualty when investigating a leakage on the Blue Funnel
vessel Idomeneus, and was in Concord Hospital unable to
see for six weeks. Although he regained his sight, he permanently
lost his senses of taste and smell as a result of exposure to
the vapours.
Le Fèvre visited most Australian universities, seeking
to recruit Australian-trained chemists for war work involving
chemical agents. In Sydney he met Professors J.C. Earl
and C.E. Fawsitt separately,
and recalled finding the Chemistry Department in a 'terrible state
of disrepair' and the front lawn of the University dug up into
air-raid trenches.
Having found an RAAF successor, he returned to the United
Kingdom in December 1943, by air via the Pacific, USA,
and the Atlantic. He resumed work at the Ministry of Aircraft
Production headquarters as an Assistant Director (Research and
Development, Armament Chemistry). In July 1945 he became Head
of the Chemistry Department, Royal Aircraft Establishment, Farnborough.
Since the authorities permitted a certain engagement in pure research,
Le Fèvre took the opportunity to investigate aspects of
diazocyanide chemistry that had been questioned in the chemical
literature of the war period. One of his duties at Farnborough
was to supervise the planning and construction of a new building
for his department, an experience that would prove of great value
a decade later when the opportunity came to build a new Chemistry
School at the University of Sydney.
The early years in Sydney
After the war, Le Fèvre was approached in London by Professor Eric Ashby
(later Lord Ashby), Chairman of the Professorial Board of the
University of Sydney from 1942 to 1944, who invited him to take
up the position of Director of Chemistry at that University.
Le Fèvre was attracted by Sydney as a city in which to
live and to bring up a family far from the memories of a war-ravaged
Europe. Moreover, the University of Sydney had a style somewhat
reminiscent of the more traditional English universities and this
too had its appeal. The teaching of chemistry there dated from
the arrival in 1852 of Professor John Smith
to take up the Chair of Chemistry and Experimental Philosophy.
Robert Robinson held the Chair of Organic Chemistry, 1913-16.
Another Nobel Laureate in the making was J.W. Cornforth
who graduated MSc in 1939. G.J. Burrows, D.P. Mellor,
F. Lions and F.P.J. Dwyer
(who for a time had a very close collaboration with R.S. Nyholm)
had made important contributions to coordination chemistry.
It was a regrettable fact that for some years prior to Le Fèvre's
arrival, Chemistry at Sydney had become implacably divided into
two groupings about Professors C.E. Fawsitt and J.C. Earl. It
was to be Le Fèvre's task to attempt a reunification. He
arrived in Sydney with his family in 1946 and in November of that
year took up duties as Professor of Chemistry. The retirement
of both Fawsitt and Earl allowed reforms in organisation to be
made and at the beginning of 1948 the two separate departments
of Chemistry and Organic Chemistry, Pure and Applied were fused
into one Chemistry School. Le Fèvre was made Head of the
School of Chemistry, a position he was to hold until his retirement
in 1970. He was to be joined in 1952 by A.J. Birch who took up
the Chair of Organic Chemistry and D.P. Craig who became the University's
first Professor of Physical Chemistry. In the course of Le Fèvre's
tenure, Birch would be replaced by C.W. Shoppee
(office 1956-69) and Craig by A.E. Alexander
(office 1956-70).
Le Fèvre's arrival in Sydney coincided with the great wave
of post-war enrolments of ex-service and other new students. This
highlighted the inadequacy of the chemistry building, something
that was quite evident even before the war. A feature of the University's
centenary celebrations in 1951 was a public appeal, and although
the appeal did not reach anywhere near its target, it did produce
an anonymous donation of £100,000 to be used for the building
of a first wing of a new Chemistry School. The donor was subsequently
disclosed to be the late Mrs. Brightie Phillips. With the promise
of further funds from the government of New South Wales, construction
began in 1955 with completion four years later, followed by an
inauguration ceremony in 1960. Le Fèvre was intimately
involved with the design and planning and with the supervision
of construction of what was regarded by many as the finest chemistry
building of any campus in Australia. D. Branagan and G. Holland
pay homage to Le Fèvre's efforts in their history of science
in the University of Sydney, Ever Reaping Something New (University
of Sydney, 1985).
Le Fèvre's period as Head was characterised by the great
impetus he gave to research. His active encouragement of research
groups within the School is reflected in the statistic that during
his first fourteen years in office the number of articles from
the School published in learned journals amounted to 680, a major
component of the University's entire research output. With the
introduction of PhD programmes in the late 1940s, a rapid increase
occurred in research student numbers and the Sydney School was
to achieve a pre-eminence in research within the Australian university
system. Le Fèvre himself had about one hundred research
students and co-authors during his term of office. His publication
list includes reviews, a book, and several hundred research papers.
Research in Sydney
Le Fèvre resumed his research work in Sydney, taking up
and extending projects commenced in England but interrupted by
the war. Much of the apparatus at University College had been
destroyed in the bombing of London so new equipment had to be
constructed for the Sydney laboratories. This was to be the beginning
of more than two decades of highly productive and innovative research
effort.
From the outset, a programme of investigation was undertaken of
the structures and configurations of a variety of diazo-compounds,
of photochemical and thermal transformations between isomeric
forms, and of the kinetics of isomerisations in solution. These
studies strongly supported Hantzsch's ideas on the structures
of diazo-compounds and led (in the best traditions of the subject!)
to controversy in the columns of Chemistry and Industry with
H.H. Hodgson of Huddersfield (see, for example, Chem. and Ind,
1948, 270). Associated with Le Fèvre in this work were
K.E. Calderbank, J. Northcott, J.D.C. Anderson, I.R. Wilson, A.A.
Hukins, P. Souter, D.D. Brown, R.N. Whittem, H.C. Freeman, T.H.
Liddicoet, I. Youhotsky and C.V. Worth. A number of infrared spectral
studies were made with M.F. O'Dwyer, R.L. Werner, J.B. Sousa,
W.T. Oh, I.H. Reece, R. Roper and M.J. Aroney, to specify the
stretching frequency of the N=N group in a range of diazo-compounds
and to identify infrared spectral features characteristic of the
diazonium cation. Working with Sousa and Roper, Le Fèvre
proceeded to investigate the kinetics of normal to iso-diazoate
transformations in strongly alkaline solutions and to make various
attempts to disentangle the complicated series of pH-dependent
equilibria between diazoates and diazonium salts. The programme
was effectively concluded in about 1963.
Early in the Sydney period, the first observations were made of
the high polarities of J.C. Earl's newly discovered 'sydnones'.
Information on molecular structures and the mesomeric effects
operative in this new class of compounds was extracted from dipole
moment and infrared spectral measurements. Interest in the sydnones
led to an examination of 'model' structures such as antipyrin
and phenylisooxazolone and to an understanding of electronic
displacements in keten and some of its derivatives. C.L. Angyal,
R.D. Brown, A.A. Hukins, E.M. Leake, G.A. Barclay and R.S. Armstrong
contributed notably to this work.
Investigation of the effects of medium and state on the apparent
dipole moments of substances, started with P. Russell and C.G.
Le Fèvre before the war, was carried forward in collaboration
with I.G. Ross, B.M. Smythe, G.A. Barclay, C.G. Le Fèvre,
J.W. Mulley, C.L. Angyal, H.G. Holland, H.C. Freeman, A.D. Buckingham,
B. Harris, E.P.A. Sullivan, D.A.A.S. Narayana Rao, J.Y.H. Chau,
F. Maramba and J. Tardif. Dielectric polarisation measurements
were made for a wide range of molecular substances in the gas,
liquid or dissolved states primarily to assess existing theoretical
treatments (Clausius-Mossotti-Debye, Onsager, Ross-Sack, and others)
as well as various empirical relations by which the 'true' or
gas-phase dipole moments of molecules could be predicted from
experiments on solutions or on pure liquids. Correlations between
solvent effects as observed from experiment and the sign of the
Kerr constant attracted particular attention. In the 1953 edition
of Dipole Moments (p.82), Le Fèvre concluded that:
None of the empirical or theoretical approaches...adequately
embraces all the known facts concerning the effects
of the medium in dipole moment measurements. Some seem valid for
the differences between µ solution and µ gas but fail when tested on pure polar liquids, others especially
produced for polar liquids are unable to cover all
such liquids.
Such studies effectively culminated in empirical equations that
fitted known data better than any others previously proposed.
Le Fèvre was able to claim that 'a method, useful in practice,
is now available for estimating µ gas from either µ
solution or µ liquid'. A postscript to this work was a
study of polarisation effects in liquids carried out with Narayana
Rao.
In parallel with the above programmes and substantially with colleagues
already named, Le Fèvre continued his long-standing interest
in the elucidation of problems of molecular structure and geometry
using dipole moments, often in conjunction with infrared and electronic
spectral data.
Examined were, inter alia, oxygen, sulphur and nitrogen
containing heterocycles, monoterpenes, oximes, 'iodoxybenzene',
substituted benzocinnoline 6-oxides, 2,2'-dipyridyl, 'diphenylmaleinitrile',
substituted aryl nitro compounds, 1,4-dioxan and the temperature
dependence of its structure, species with possible keto-enol tautomerism,
and solute intermolecular interactions. Other topics that interested
Le Fèvre in his first decade in Sydney included the thermotropy
of spiro-pyrans and thermochromism of methyleneanthrones;
the a priori calculation of atomic polarisations from spectroscopic
data; and the influence of molecular shape and of medium characteristics
on the dielectric relaxation times of dipolar solutes. About the
mid-1960s, he was invited to write 'Dipole Moments (Electrical
and Magnetic) for The Encyclopedia of Physics.
As mentioned earlier, among other investigations laid aside for
the war was one concerning the Kerr effect and the uses that this
phenomenon might have in chemistry. The effect, known since 1875,
occurs when a voltage is applied to a dielectric causing it to
become doubly refracting, i.e. the refractive index at a given
wavelength is different in directions parallel and perpendicular
to the applied field. The magnitude and sign of the measured effect
depends on the 'Kerr constant' which is related to the structure
of the molecules forming the medium and their electronic properties.
Equipment for measurement of the Kerr effect was reconstructed
in Sydney (incorporating remnants of the pre-war apparatus that
had survived) and the programme was restarted in 1947. Financial
help was forthcoming, mainly from Imperial Chemical Industries,
Australia and New Zealand Limited. The UCL-Sydney activities
were the subject of Le Fèvre's Presidential Address to
Section B of ANZAAS at the 1955 Melbourne meeting, which
was titled 'The Kerr Effect in Chemistry'. To quote from pp.41-42:
Experience before the war had shown two things: the difficulty
of taking electric double refraction observations on vaporized
materials, and the necessity of extracting useful information
from measurements made on solutions. As the mathematical formulae
for the Kerr effect were strictly applicable only to gaseous dielectrics,
the full usefulness of this property to chemists was limited,
since many interesting substances could not be vaporized without
decomposition. In 1947 the whole situation had some analogies
with that in which dipole moments were being measured about 1920.
It seemed fundamentally necessary therefore that the possibilities
of examining materials as solutes, and ultimately securing some
value for these solutes at infinite dilution, should be explored.
This was made the first objective of the Sydney work.
By 1953, Professor and Mrs Le Fèvre had devised and tested
a method whereby the electric double refraction of a solute, expressed
as the quantity mKsolute (the solute molar Kerr constant at infinite
dilution) could meaningfully be extracted from experiments in
solution. Using a modified form of the classical theory of Langevin
and Born, they were able to obtain, from mKsolute, the anisotropy
of polarisability of the solute molecule. As well, it was shown
that for polar solutes the ratios mKsolute / mKgas roughly resemble
the corresponding µ2solute / µ2gas values, thus
making it possible to calculate approximate gas-state Kerr constants
from solution measurements. The Le Fèvre solution-state
approach was regarded by H.A. Stuart and others in the field as
an important achievement, especially since previous efforts had
yielded indifferent results. It was to become clear with further
work that the treatment should be restricted to observations made
in non-polar media such as carbon tetrachloride, cyclohexane or
dioxan. Nonetheless, wide fields of applications were opened.
A full account detailing the theory, the technique of measurement,
and results to hand at the time, appeared in 1955. Further results
to 1959 were collated in 'The Kerr Effect', Chapter XXXVI of Physical
Methods of Organic Chemistry, ed. A. Weissberger (with C.G.
Le Fèvre), and in Le Fèvre's Liversidge Lecture.
Progress up to the end of 1964 was summarised by Le Fèvre
in 'Molecular Refractivity and Polarisability' in Advances
in Physical Organic Chemistry, ed. V. Gold, wherein Le Fèvre
placed particular emphasis on the application of the Kerr effect
to stereo-structural problems. He illustrated this with the tabulation
of a wide range of examples investigated in the Sydney laboratories.
In a further account in 1970, 'Polarisation and Polarisability
in Chemistry', Le Fèvre discussed the central nature of
the polarisability concept in relation to molecular interaction,
transition states, reaction pathways, energetics, and kinetics.
His final overview was written, with C.G. Le Fèvre, about
the time of his retirement: 'The Kerr Effect', Chapter VI of Physical
Methods of Chemistry eds. A. Weissberger and B. Rossiter.
The Le Fèvres analysed Kerr constants from solution, together
with solute dipole moments (in the case of polar substances) and
molar electron polarisation data (the latter from molecular refractivity
dispersion), to determine the molecular principal polarisabilities
for solutes such as methyl and t-butyl halides, chloroform,
benzene, a number of 1,3,5-trisubstituted and hexasubstituted
benzenes which, because of their symmetry, are associated with
polarisability ellipsoids of revolution. They were able to extend
the method to molecules such as mono- and di-substituted methyl-,
halogeno- and nitro-benzenes, pyridine, quinoline and acetone
which, because of their lower symmetry, required additional data
for specification of the polarisability tensors. This was provided,
in the first instance, by recourse to early measurements in the
literature of the depolarisation factor for light scattered transversely
by a substance (from J. Cabannes, La diffusion moléculaire
de la lumière, 1929). in this way the Le Fèvres
were able to provide valuable information on solute polarisability,
a measure of the electronic response to a perturbing field for
particular directions within the molecular framework. A weakness
in the procedure, however, was uncertainty as to the appropriateness
of the light scattering data, which derived from measurements
on gases or pure liquids. The problem was addressed by Le Fèvre,
working with B. Purnachandra Rao, in the 1956-60 period. They
developed a method of determining solute anisotropies from measurements
of depolarisation factors of light scattered by solutions. With
the aid of a grant from the Nuffield Foundation, they constructed
apparatus based at first on the Cornu visual technique but modified
later for photometric detection. This work placed on a firmer
foundation the determination of anisotropic polarisabilities for
solute molecules. Prior to this development, Le Fèvre had
advanced a number of approximate methods of estimating polarisability
along a specific molecular principal axis. These were based on:
(a) the interpolation of values for members of a related group
of molecules where regular trends in polarisability had been observed,
as in the methyl-substituted benzenes; (b) a rough correlation
which had been found between ratios of molecular dimensions and
directional polarisabilities; or (c) the use of crystal-state refractive
index and density measurements as was found appropriate for naphthalene.
With the determination of polarisability tensors for a substantial
number of molecules of known geometry, the Le Fèvres proceeded
to test the notion, suggested by E.H. Meyer and G. Otterbein
(Physik.Z, 32, [1931] 290), that polarisability parameters
can sensibly be ascribed to discrete molecular segments such as
individual bonds. From dissection of the molecular values, Le
Fèvre was able to set up an extensive scheme of anisotropic
polarisabilities for bonds commonly encountered in organic molecules.
A compilation of bond polarisabilities to 1965 was presented by
Le Fèvre in his chapter in Advances in Physical Organic
Chemistry. It was stated, however, that the anisotropy of a
given bond should not be regarded as a 'universal' constant since
it could be affected by the structural environment and particularly
so by conjugation or mutual induction. Comparisons made between
the C-X group polarisabilities (X=halogen, Me, NO2 or CN) of
aliphatic and aromatic structures showed small polarisability
augmentations (exaltations) to occur along the C(aryl)-X bond
axis with slight diminutions in directions perpendicular to that
axis. The evidence, Le Fèvre wrote, correlated with 'the
non-classical polarisability mechanisms long used in organic chemistry
to formulate the temporary transmission of electrical effects
from group to group or from substituent to reactive position (3)'.
A safe viewpoint, adopted by Le Fèvre, was that the apparent
bond polarisabilities drawn from measurements on solutes should
be regarded as empirical and that they may appropriately be applied
to molecular situations analogous to those from which they were
derived. A very considerable body of evidence justifying this
was accumulated over the years, reference to which is made in
the Le Fèvres' 1972 contribution to Physical Methods
of Chemistry. Ancillary work involved devising empirical correlations
between polarisability components and the dimensions of bonded
atomic groupings, bond vibrational stretching frequencies and
wavelengths of maximum absorption of the K-band in conjugated
diphenylpolyenes, and the calculation from bond polarisabilities
of optical rotatory powers.
The determination of bond polarisabilities as well as polarisability
tensors for larger molecular segments such as phenyl, amide and
other groups, though important, was regarded by Le Fèvre
as the precursor phase to what can only be described as an enormous
programme of study of the Kerr effect in relation to the stereo-structural
analysis of molecules in solution. It had long been understood
that the magnitude and sign of the Kerr effect could at times
provide qualitative information about molecular geometry; for
example thianthren, having a negative Kerr constant, must (from
theory) be folded about a line joining the sulphur atoms. Phenazine,
on the other hand, has a positive Kerr constant and is planar.
The procedure most often used by Le Fèvre was to compute
the molecular polarisability tensors (using component group parameters)
and thence the molar Kerr constants for the various possible stereo-structures
and to compare the latter with the molar Kerr constant from experiment.
The power of the method, due in large measure to the fact that
the Kerr constant is often greatly sensitive to variations of
molecular geometry, was recognised early in the Sydney programme.
Measured also, as a matter of routine, was the permanent dipole
moment (as it came into the equations for the Kerr effect with
polar molecules), and in many cases this assisted in the stereochemical
analysis from dipole vector considerations. The techniques were
used in a complementary manner. Apparent in Le Fèvre's
later work of the 1960s is a greater use of other physical methods,
notably nuclear magnetic resonance and infrared spectroscopy,
to provide information that facilitated analysis of the Kerr effect,
often through defining and/or limiting the range of confirmational
possibilities. In the period 1955-71, Le Fèvre and his
co-workers investigated the molecular stereo-structures in solution
of a wide range of compounds.
It was Le Fèvre's grand design to establish the Kerr effect
technique as a method of importance in molecular stereochemical
analysis, and to prove this to be the case by applying it to a
great number of substances to obtain information on solute geometry
that was not readily accessible or not available at all from other
techniques. In his 1965 chapter in Advances in Physical Organic
Chemistry, he was able to conclude that:
The majority of the procedures currently being used in the
confirmational analysis of solutes (e.g. infrared absorption differences
between conformers, optical rotatory dispersion, NMR proton shifts,
etc.) are qualitative and based upon empirical observations and
analogies. It is therefore claimed that the present applications
of anisotropic polarisabilities, built as they are on the theoretical
arguments of Lorentz, Lorenz, Langevin, Born, Gans, Debye, and
others, have where solutes are concerned advantages both in
their foundations and in the quantitatively expressible natures
of the conclusions they can provide.
In many of the 'confirmational papers' quoted above, evidence
was presented for various electronic effects in molecules. As
well, studies were made specifically to probe electromeric interactions,
usually by seeking correlation between the observed polarisability
exaltation and the direction of the delocalisation pathway, in
aniline, toluene, t-butylbenzene, benzotrichloride and
their para-substituted derivatives). In other work, Le
Fèvre and J.M. Eckert used structure determination by the
Kerr effect to examine steric courses for the replacement of hydroxyl
by chlorine in cis-2-decalol. Also they were able to apply
the Kerr effect to the conformational analysis of natural product
derivatives such as those of cholesterol, tropine and y-pelletierine.
Some aspects of this were followed up, with C.Y. Chen, in a series
of 1H NMR and IR spectral investigations of compounds with 6-membered
heterocyclic systems. The observation in some instances of non-linear
relationships between solute concentration and the Kerr effect
or the dielectric polarisation led to investigations that showed
solute-solute intermolecular associations of particular geometry
to occur in solutions of benzyl alcohol, aniline and substituted
anilines, normal alcohols, triisopropanolamine borate, tetrabutoxytitanium,
carboxylic acids, and mercury(II) chloride. The Kerr effect
technique was applied also to determining overall polarisability
anisotropies and the morphologies of macromolecular species dissolved
in non-polar media. Other parts of the programme involved studies
of possible conformational changes in flexible molecules with
variation of the dielectric characteristics of the medium; the
influence of solvent on the apparent solute molar Kerr constant;
wavelength dispersion of the Kerr constant; polarisabilities of
non-bonding electron pairs; the temperature-independent component
of the Kerr constant; and dispersion of dielectric absorption
in the microwave region as applied to problems of 'anomalous atomic
polarity', molecular structure and rigidity. Working with G.L.D.
Ritchie, a more sensitive version of the apparatus for solutions
was constructed and applied to measuring Kerr constants of gases
and to deriving molecular and bond polarisabilities appropriate
to this state. Other developments in the experimental technique,
carried out with R.K. Pierens, involved the use of sinusoidal
or of pulsed voltages the latter found particular application
in the measurement of the Kerr constants of weakly conducting
solutions of substances such as keto-enol mixtures.
Other issues were to emerge from the main theme of Le Fèvre's
research. One such was the application of the Kerr effect to investigating
solvation. It had been noted in the earlier work that solute Kerr
constants from benzene solutions sometimes differed markedly from
those obtained from carbon tetrachloride or cyclohexane. This
was eventually attributed to time-averaged non-random packing
of the anisotropic benzene molecules about the solute, a notion
supported by NMR evidence at the time. Le Fèvre and his
colleagues used observed aromatic solvent-induced changes of the
solute Kerr constant, with concomitant 1H NMR, dipole moment and
dielectric absorption data, to specify some stereochemical aspects
of the interactions of polar molecules in these solvents. A somewhat
similar approach was applied to studying p-hydrogen bonding as found
for fluoroform in benzene, p-p-donor-acceptor
complexes, and co-ordination of vanadylacetylacetonate with dioxan.
Concurrently with the above programmes, Le Fèvre launched
a study in the early 1960s of the magnetic birefringence of molecular
diamagnetic substances. The magnetic analogue of the Kerr effect,
the Cotton-Mouton effect, was known to be related by theory to
the molecular polarisability and magnetisability. A procedure
was developed whereby Cotton-Mouton constants from solution could
be used together with analogous Kerr effect data to obtain solute
molecular magnetic anisotropies and, in many cases, the principal
molecular magnetisabilities. The examination was undertaken of
a large number of aromatics, primarily substituted benzenes, polynuclear
hydrocarbons, heterocyclic compounds, and quinones. In cases where
comparisons could be made, reasonable agreement was usually found
with literature values of solid-state magnetic anisotropies obtained
by crystal-torsion or crystal-oscillation methods. Indeed, one
of the attractions of the technique to Le Fèvre was that
it provided an independent and accessible physical property from
which it was sometimes possible to derive polarisability data
complementary to those from the Kerr effect. Trends in magnetisabilities
were observed and interpreted in terms of a tentative bond magnetisability
scheme.
A prime motivation was the hope that the magnetic anisotropies
from experiment would provide a quantitative measure of electron
delocalisation and, by inference, of aromatic character. Studied
also was the dependence of solute Cotton-Mouton constants on benzene
solvation. Le Fèvre's final publication in this series,
before he retired from his Sydney post, reported the investigation
of about forty pure aliphatic liquids and was concerned with the
relationship between pure liquid and solution-state molar Cotton-Mouton
constants.
More than seventy research students and colleagues were associated
with Le Fèvre in studies of the Kerr and Cotton-Mouton
effects and Rayleigh scattering. They included the following:
C.G. Le Fèvre, M.J. Aroney, R.S. Armstrong, G.L.D. Ritchie,
R.K. Pierens, J.M. Eckert, A.J. Williams, K.E. Calderbank, B.
Purnachandra Rao, D.V. Radford, R. Bramley, L. Radom, P.J. Stiles,
B.J. Orr, P.H. Cureton, E.P.A. Sullivan, D.S.N. Murthy, C.Y. Chen,
J.D. Saxby, K.M.S. Sundaram, A. Sundaram, K.R. Skamp and L.H.L.
Chia.
Le Fèvre's Sydney work of the 1950s and 1960s greatly enhanced
his reputation as a physical-organic chemist of international
standing. His election in 1959 as a Fellow of the Royal Society
bears testimony to the distinction of 'his research in organic
and physical organic chemistry'. It is pertinent to quote from
Sir Christopher Ingold's preface to the Festschrift compiled in
1970 by colleagues of Professor Le Fèvre to celebrate his
sixty-fifth birthday. Ingold says:
Le Fèvre's work on molecular electric anisotropy is
so outstandingly original, so complete in its grand conception,
such a major creation in physical organic chemistry...
It is remarkable that all that we now know of the electronic
polarisability of molecules as a function of direction comes almost
entirely from the work of the Sydney School. The unique quality
of the record, as well as its massive character, is a matter for
congratulations...
Professional and community activities
Le Fèvre's prodigious efforts in research appeared not
to detract from his attention to other responsibilities. He was
acknowledged to be a conscientious and able administrator. That
he was a teacher of quality is undoubtedly true. His lectures
and seminars were those of the enthusiast, yet presented with
sincerity and style a reflection of the man himself. Le Fèvre
was philosophically committed to a specialist first-year teaching
group (to be supplemented and assisted by other, more research-orientated,
members of staff) to cater for the needs of between 1,500 and
2,100 first-year students about three-quarters of whom were in
service courses for Faculties other than Science. The varied and
complex needs of these students were for the period of Le Fèvre's
tenure well catered for by the teaching group, initially under
the directorship of J.J. Broe and later under A.J. Harle. Le Fèvre's
administrative headship of the Chemistry School, spanning twenty-two
years, encompassed a number of difficult periods, beginning with
the tearing down of emotional and physical barriers to departmental
amalgamation in 1948, surviving in the early years an era of great
acrimony (some of it in the public arena), and negotiating periods
of very rapid growth and of severe economic stringency. What cannot
be denied is that within a few years of his arrival, Sydney was
flourishing as a centre of chemical learning and postgraduate
research. Perhaps this is the best testimony to Le Fèvre's
achievements.
He found time also for participation in extra mural academic and
professional activities. He was a Fellow of the Royal Institute
of Chemistry and of the Royal Australian Chemical Institute, serving
as Vice-President and New South Wales Branch President of the
latter and being its Smith Medallist for 1952. He was a Foundation
Fellow of the Australian Academy of Science (1954) and was one
of the Petitioners to Her Majesty the Queen for a Royal Charter.
Le Fèvre became a member of the first Council of the Academy.
Before emigrating, he had served two periods of office on the
Council of the Chemical Society in London. He twice served as
a member of the Council of the Royal Society of New South Wales,
1948-51 and 1961-74; in 1960 he was the Liversidge Lecturer and
in 1961 the President of this Society. Of historical importance
was a chapter titled 'The Establishment of Chemistry within Australian
Science Contributions from New South Wales' in A Century
of Scientific Progress, the centenary volume of the Royal Society of New South Wales, published in 1968, in which he traces
the growth of chemistry in New South Wales from the establishment
of the colony to the retirement of Archibald Liversidge in 1907
from the Chair of Chemistry and Mineralogy at Sydney. He was the
Society's Medallist in 1969. At the Melbourne meetings of the
Australian and New Zealand Association for the Advancement of
Science in 1955 and 1967, Le Fèvre was respectively President
of Section B and Masson Lecturer. Other distinctions include:
Coronation Medallist (1953); Fellow, Queen Mary College, London
(1962) Chemical Society of London Lecturer for Australia (1968).
He was at various times a member of the following: Australian
Journal of Chemistry editorial board, Society of Chemical
Industry (Sydney Section) committee, Advisory Committee on Buildings
for the Australian National University, Australian Broadcasting
Commission Science Panel, Department of Supply and Development
Chemical Sub-Committee, and the New South Wales Department of
Public Health Pure Foods Advisory Committee. During 1947-48 he
was a trustee of the Mitchell Library, Sydney, and a member of
the Developmental Council set up by the Minister for Education
to form an Institute (or a University) of Technology in New South
Wales. He was a trustee of the Museum of Applied Arts and Sciences
(1946-75) and a member of the Rotary Club of Sydney from 1948
till his retirement. Sir Mark Oliphant,
a physicist and founding member of the Australian Academy of Science,
sums up succinctly the feelings of many of Le Fèvre's colleagues:
Raymond was one of the earliest, and most valuable fellows
of the Australian Academy of Science. He played a significant
part in getting the young Academy off the ground, and in making
it respectable, for his standards were high and his knowledge
of procedures profound.
Raymond's attitude towards science, and its responsibilities,
as well as its benefits, for mankind generally, reflected his
caring personality and I learnt much in discussion of such questions
with him.
His company, and that of Cathie, were always enjoyable. We
looked forward to the occasions when we could meet. He had a true
sense of humour, without malice or rancour. He never boasted or
sought the limelight, but his stature as a scientist is clear
from the fact that he was elected to the Royal Society of London
as an Australian chemist.
The memory of Raymond warms my heart, for, to paraphrase a
quotation used by Chadwick of Rutherford, 'he was a good man,
who did good things'.
Personal
At the age of sixty-three, Le Fèvre suffered a heart attack
but was able to resume his duties after a period of convalescence.
His love for research was undiminished and it was with great sadness
that in 1970, having reached the compulsory retiring age of sixty-five,
he was obliged to vacate his Sydney laboratories. Le Fèvre
was made Emeritus Professor in 1971 and thereafter he moved to
Macquarie University at North Ryde where he continued his research
as an Honorary Professorial Fellow. His contributions to the University
of Sydney were honoured in 1985, the year of the Science Centenary,
by the award of a Doctorate of Science honoris causa.
An extremely modest man, Le Fèvre seemed almost oblivious
of honours or esteem accorded him. An exception, perhaps, was
his stated appreciation of the unusual honour bestowed on him
with his inclusion on the 'wall of fame' at the Technion in Haifa,
Israel.
He made generous donations in recent years to, inter alia,
Queen Mary College, the University of Sydney, and Macquarie
University. In each of these recipient institutions, the decision
was made that such funds be used to establish awards to younger
chemists.
Raymond Le Fèvre's record of achievement, though great,
tells only part of the story. Some other aspects of his life deserve
special mention. He was blessed with an extraordinarily happy
marriage with Catherine, his wife of fifty-five years. It was
a trusting, loving relationship, enhanced by their two children,
Nicolette and Ian. They were totally supportive of each other
in matters personal, in regard to their family, in times of happiness
and of sadness. The tragic loss of their son Ian in November 1977
brought them, if anything, even closer together. It was, to all
who knew them, the complete partnership. Catherine's research
contributions led to the award to her of a DSc by the University
of London (1960). In the 1960s she became very much involved with
research issues of social importance such as the drug problem
in New South Wales and, later on, with aspects of forensic science.
To generations of Sydney science graduates, Raymond Le Fèvre
was an inspiration. He propagated to so many that which he himself
felt, the excitement of exploration in science. Many of his past
students now occupy senior posts in academia and elsewhere testimony,
in large measure, to his example and encouragement. He will be
remembered as a warm, gregarious man with a subtle and gently
wicked humour. Above all, he was compassionate and feeling a
man who evoked loyalty and deep affection.
It is fitting that Cathie, in whose arms he died, should have
shared his odyssey.
Acknowledgements
The authors are very grateful to Dr Catherine G. Le Fèvre
for making available papers dealing with Professor Le Fèvre's
early life and wartime experiences, for providing the photograph,
and for her helpful comments. We are indebted also to Dr R.S.
Armstrong, Professor R. Bonnett, Professor D.P. Craig,
F.R.S., Professor H.J.A. Dartnall, Professor M. Davies, Dr J.M.
Eckert, Professor P.H. Gore, Mr A.J. Harle, Dr H.G. Holland, Professor
L.E. Lyons, Professor Sir Mark Oliphant, F.R.S., Professor
B.J. Orr, Dr B. Purnachandra Rao, Professor G.L.D. Ritchie, Professor
I.G. Ross, Dr P.J. Stiles, and Professor W.C. Taylor. Most of
all, we are indebted to the late Professor Le Fèvre for
his beautiful autobiographical material from which we have quoted
at length.
Notes
(1) M.M. Harris, Chemistry
and Industry, 1966, 1953; C.K. Ingold, Biographical Memoirs
of Fellows of the Royal Society, 14 (1968), 449.
(2) Contribution to the 1983
Australian Department of Defence account, Mustard Gas Field
Trials during World War II, by R.G. Gillis. Australian Government
released for publication, June 1988.
(3) C.K. Ingold, Structure
and Mechanism in Organic Chemistry, Cornell University Press,
1953.
M.J. Aroney, School of Chemistry, University of Sydney.
A.D. Buckingham, University Chemical Laboratory, Cambridge, U.K.
|