Harnessing direct solar energy a progress reportWe often hear about solar car challenges and solar heating, but will solar energy ever be a major energy source for industrial societies?
Key text
Back to basics You will get more from this topic if you have mastered the basics of energy this link will take you to an annotated list of sites with helpful background information. Key textCan society meet its energy needs without pollution? Alternative energy sources are far less polluting than traditional fuels, although they may have other drawbacks. One source of alternative energy is the sun. The Earth is bathed in huge amounts of the sun’s energy. We can use this solar energy directly, simply by capturing sunlight. Solar energy is our oldest energy source Humans have always used the sun’s energy directly (eg, for drying clothes and foodstuffs), as well as indirectly to power the agriculture that supplies us with food. This century we have started to use solar energy more effectively, and it is likely that we’ll increase its use in the future. It’s reliable, free and clean, but... The great feature of solar energy is the fact that it is likely to continue to exist so far into the future that we can think of it as being unending. It is, therefore, a form of renewable energy. This is a big contrast with non-renewable energy sources, most of which are running out as we use them. In addition, using solar energy doesn’t cause air pollution or involve damaging the Earth’s surface. It requires no difficult and expensive extraction procedures. But the main problem is what to do when the sun doesn’t shine. The times when we most need energy when it is dark or cold are when sunlight is least available. But there are possible ways around this, so read on... Compared to fossil fuels, sunlight is a weak energy source Capturing sunlight is not as easy as it sounds. It is a dilute energy source, spread out over time and space. Earth receives 5.6 x 1018 (5,600,000,000,000,000,000) megajoules of solar radiation each year (Box 1: Eliminating the zeroes), but to make it worthwhile we need to collect it over many hours and across many square metres of ground. We then need to concentrate it so as to make available the sort of power that modern society needs. Sunlight is not as ‘energy-dense’ as oil but this is made up for by the fact that it is present over such a large area. By careful design and positioning of houses we can use sunlight to warm our homes and our domestic water. This passive solar heating can help us reduce fossil fuel use (and save money) but it’s not enough to replace those traditional fuels entirely. To be most useful, the energy in sunlight must be converted to another form Solar energy becomes much more useful when we change it to another form. Light can be changed directly to an electric current by photovoltaic cells. The efficiency with which these convert light to electricity is still too low, and their cost too high, to make them useful for many applications. Furthermore, you need to have a large area of photovoltaic cells to power something like a car although it can be done, as demonstrated by the entrants in the World Solar Challenge car rally (Box 2: Driving on a sunbeam). Australian research is forging ahead on reducing the cost and improving the efficiency of photovoltaic cells (Box 3: Light to electricity). Many places where energy is needed are not very sunny Unfortunately, we can’t yet power our homes entirely on sunlight. Photovoltaic cells for a house are expensive, and anyway most houses are not in the sunniest part of Australia or the world. The solution is to put the sun’s energy into a form which can be stored and moved around, so that we can collect it in those places where most of it falls and move it to where it is needed. Steam or hydrogen gas are the best future conversion options Sunlight can be concentrated by solar collectors best sited in a desert. These focus sunlight from a large area on to a central vessel in which water is heated to become very high temperature steam. The expanding steam can power a turbine and generate electricity on a sufficiently large scale that it can be sent across a power grid. The world’s largest, free-standing, steerable solar concentrating dish is in Canberra, where it forms part of the Australian National University’s solar research program (Box 4: The Big Dish). The greatest challenge for solar energy is to power modern society’s transport and industrial needs. Transport fuels must be light but packed with energy. They must also operate when it’s dark, so photovoltaic cells are out. The answer for the future probably lies in hydrogen gas, derived from water split apart using solar electricity or the sun’s concentrated heat (Box 5: Chemical fuels from the sun). Related Nova topics: Generating new ideas for meeting future energy needs Biomass the growing energy resource Which way ahead for hydrogen cars?
The quickest way around all these problems is to use the simple mathematical method of writing very large or very small numbers, a method used by all scientists too. This form of writing numbers essentially relies on counting zeroes and is called using powers of 10 or exponents. Everyone knows what squaring a number means it is multiplying a number by itself. Thus, 3 squared is 9. The mathematical way of writing this is 32 = 9. The little number 2 above the 3 is called an exponent. 32 can also be spoken of as three to the power of two. The square of 10 is 100; so 102 = 100. You can say this as ‘ten to the power of two’, or just ‘ten to the two’. If the exponent is 3, then the number is multiplied by itself once again. So, 33 = 3 × 3 × 3 = 27, and 103 = 10 × 10 × 10 = 1000. You may have noticed that when dealing in powers of 10, the exponent is the same as the number of zeroes in the number, as this table shows:
101 = 10
Of course, not all large numbers are always full of zeroes. Suppose we have the number 2,720,000 (two million, seven hundred and twenty thousand). You could call this 2.72 million, or just multiply 2.72 by the appropriate power of 10 for one million. As the million has six zeroes, the exponent would be 6, and the number would be expressed as 2.72 × 106.
Rounding numbers up or down
If a number is more precise, such as 2,738,458, we can either express it as it is, express it using an exponential but keeping all the figures (2.738458 × 106), or round it up or down. Whether we round it or not depends on whether the number is describing a precisely quantifiable thing. For example, if the figure is a calculated average (eg, the number of bacteria found on each square metre of rainforest topsoil), then rounding it is valid. We cannot be sure of the number down to the last bacterium, and even as we are estimating it, the bacterial population is changing. In this case, we would approximate the number as 2.74 × 106 or 2.7 × 106, or even just 3 × 106.
Very small numbers
Very small numbers are also conveniently expressed using powers of 10. In this case, a minus sign is written before the exponent. For example, one-thousandth is 10-3, one-millionth is 10-6, which we say as ‘ten to the minus six’. The exponents represent the zeroes that would come after the decimal point, and the one that comes before it. A concept like 0.0000345 millimetre is hard to grasp and not easily compared with 0.00000345 millimetre (who bothers to count the zeroes?), but the difference is more obvious when they are written as 3.45 × 10-5 millimetre and 3.45 × 10-6 millimetre respectively as there is a clear difference between the exponents 5 and 6. The first number is 10 times less small (which means 10 times larger) that the second. You can practise using power-of-ten notation either with pure numbers or in combination with units. For example, using exponents, express:
Answers
The rules state that each car’s solar cells can only cover an area of 8 square metres, which is slightly less than the area of a small bathroom. And the cells can’t stretch out from the car like giant wings! But with a lightweight car and an efficient battery for storing extra power when the sun is bright, a solar car can manage a speed of 100 kilometres per hour and can continue though usually much more slowly on cloudy days or when the sun is low in the sky. Of course, the cars in the solar challenge are expensive ‘one-offs’ and are not your average family sedan. Solar-powered motoring is still some way from being accessible to everyone. But it’s a start in the same way that the great air races from Paris to London in the early part of this century honed the skills of aircraft designers, so that it eventually became possible to send jumbo jets around the world. Probably the first widely used solar vehicles will be small cars with roof-mounted photovoltaic cells, batteries for electricity storage, and the ability to top up with mains electricity when left in the garage. Designed for commuting short distances in the suburbs, they will be built with the know-how accumulating from events like the World Solar Challenge. And when these vehicles do roll off the production line, we’ll all breathe more easily as a result! Related sites
Martin Green and Stuart Wenham, from the University of New South Wales, have invented or co-invented seven distinct cell technologies over the past 15 years. These solar cells have held the world efficiency record for converting sunlight into electricity for more than a decade and last year achieved an efficiency of 24.5 per cent, the current world record by a large margin.
The awarding of the 1999 Australia Prize in Energy Science and Technology to Martin Green and Stuart Wenham represents only the second time in the 10 year history of the Prize that it’s been won by an all-Australian team an indication of the pair’s dominance in the world of photovoltaic research.
There is more information about the winners and their research at the ABC's The Lab.
Read on to find out how photovoltaic cells work.
Photovoltaic cells convert light directly into electricity. It has been known for more than 150 years that light can have an effect on the electrical properties of some materials. This is known as the photoelectric effect. In 1921, Einstein received the Nobel prize for his work explaining this. Photovoltaic cells are based on a related phenomenon called the photovoltaic effect, and interest in this has increased greatly during this century. The generation of electricity from light relies upon the separation of positive and negative electric charges electrons and positively charged 'holes', both generated by the light at the junction between two parts of a semiconductor crystal. Silicon is a semiconductor that can be mixed with tiny quantities of impurities (such as phosphorus and boron) in a process called doping. Doping can produce P (for positive) and N (for negative) materials. A photovoltaic cell is simply a wafer of semiconductor in which there is a junction between N and P materials. On exposure to light, a photovoltaic cell produces a voltage of about 1 volt, comparable with that of a torch battery. The silicon, which is expensive to make in pure form, is in the form of a thin wafer, to catch as much light as possible. The ultimate efficiency of a silicon photovoltaic cell in converting sunlight to electrical energy is less than 30 per cent, and the Photovoltaic Research Centre at the University of New South Wales holds the present world record with a cell efficiency of about 25 per cent. But cells like this, made from single-crystal silicon, are expensive, and large areas of them are needed to produce useful amounts of power. The search is therefore on for much cheaper cells without too much sacrifice in efficiency. In 1997 the National Australia Day Council acknowledged the importance of this work when it named Professor Martin Green, Director of the Photovoltaic Special Research Centre, as an Australian Achiever. Several promising lines are being pursued by the University of New South Wales and by Pacific Solar, a joint company formed by the University and Pacific Power, the major New South Wales electricity supply authority. Instead of cutting slices from specially grown silicon single crystals, one possibility involves growing thin films of silicon on much cheaper polycrystalline silicon wafers; another involves evaporating thin films of silicon onto glass plates. Initial results for both of these techniques are very encouraging, and the efficiency is already approaching 20 per cent. Another approach is to use amorphous (glassy) silicon (which can be produced fairly cheaply) instead of crystalline material. While expensive photovoltaic cells can be used in solar car races, and solar photovoltaic modules on the roofs of houses may also become common, the ultimate aim of photovoltaic technology is to produce large amounts of electrical power from cheap photovoltaic cells, connected together to give a high voltage, and to convert this to alternating current to feed into the power grid. This has already been done on an experimental scale in Sydney, and Australia is a leader in the race. Related sites
As its name implies, this solar collector is shaped like a satellite receiving dish. It is actually a solar thermal generator because it relies on heat. The huge curved mirror the dish focuses sunlight onto a central container where water is super-heated to steam at a temperature of 1500°C. If you’ve seen how steam at 100°C will escape from a kettle, you’ll appreciate how a much higher temperature could cause even a small amount of steam to expand with massive pressure. This can be used to do work in this case driving a special generator that produces electricity. The dish is steerable, so it can track the sun across the sky. Because it is always facing towards the sun, it gathers the maximum amount of energy. The dish isn’t just used for experimentation it pumps 80 kilowatts of electricity into the Australian Capital Territory’s grid. With the success of the Big Dish, and using the know-how of the project’s director Professor Stephen Kaneff and his team at the Australian National University, plans are underway to set up a working demonstration plant to provide a hefty 2 megawatts of electricity for Tennant Creek, in the Northern Territory. Related sites
Solar energy can help to produce energy in a portable form In Australia, the CSIRO Division of Energy Technology, in collaboration with Pacific Power, has tested the idea of using high temperatures from concentrated solar energy to drive a chemical reaction between carbon dioxide and methane in the presence of a chemical catalyst. The resulting gas (a mixture of hydrogen and carbon monoxide) can then be stored and transported; it releases energy (which can be changed into electricity) when it is allowed to separate back into its two component gases. These can then be recombined with a further energy input from solar power. Advantages of hydrogen as a fuel But for many in the field, it’s clear that the ultimate fuel is hydrogen the lightest substance in the universe. We can produce hydrogen from water, but need energy to do so. Once we have the hydrogen gas, it can be safely stored and transported. Hydrogen is currently only used to power rockets, but with some modifications it could power all our transport and electricity generators. When burnt, hydrogen releases energy and combines with oxygen in the air to form water a product with no pollution potential! At the same time, the water that was used to produce the hydrogen is regenerated so the cycle can continue until the sun burns out. Ways to generate hydrogen Hydrogen can be generated from water by using an electric current; this is called electrolysis. The electricity can be derived from sunlight. Another possibility would be to simply use very high temperatures from concentrated sunlight, which can literally tear apart the molecules of water into its hydrogen and oxygen atoms. Ideally the gases would then be separated. But there are much more sophisticated ways of splitting water using sunlight. The secret lies in plants. When exposed to light, green plants continually split water releasing the oxygen into the air for us to breathe, and combining the hydrogen with carbon dioxide to form sugars. If we could duplicate this process, we would be well on the way to becoming a truly solar society. Research continues. The future of hydrogen as an energy source Australia’s Sir Mark Oliphant, the distinguished physicist, is one of several experts who consider that the move to a solar-powered ‘hydrogen’ society will eventually come. If he is right, desert areas could be used for intensive solar collection and the production of liquid fuels would power our world, in much the same way that modern agriculture, with its huge area of wheatfields, continually converts sunlight into solid chemical energy for us to eat. If this comes about, those countries with a large area receiving intense sunlight such as Australia could be as rich as today’s oil-exporters. Related Nova topics:
Teachers notes Photovoltaic cells convert light directly into electricity. Most photovoltaic cells are based on silicon. When light strikes the junction in a thin slice of silicon, it causes a movement of electrons. Photovoltaic cells have no moving parts to wear out and produce no polluting waste products. Solar collectors focus sunlight from a large area on to a central vessel in which water is heated to become very high temperature steam. The expanding steam can power a turbine and generate electricity. This can be done on a large enough scale that it can be sent across a power grid. Alternatively the heat may be used to drive a chemical reaction resulting in a transportable substance that can release its energy later possibly to be turned into electricity.
Teachers notes Sunshine is not the same as daylight. Calculations in this activity are only very approximate because we are not taking into account the fact that photovoltaic cells can work in daylight without sunshine, albeit at a reduced rate.
Teachers notes Biomass, wind energy, wave energy and hydroelectricity could also be used as topics. Students should be able to show how these forms of energy originate from the sun.
Teachers notes Students' answers should cover the costs involved in collecting solar energy, for example:
Materials (for small group) wide test tube (about 4 centimetres in diameter) glass tube about the same width as the test tube (or a second test tube with the bottom cut off) 2 lengths of glass tubing 2 corks (or bungs) with two holes in each cold water food colouring thermometer
Set up the apparatus (as shown in the diagram) and place it in direct sunlight. Record the temperature of the water in the tube every two minutes until there is no further evidence of the movement of water through the system. Questions
Teachers notes
Materials (for small group) large cardboard tray, approximately 60 × 30 × 15 × centimetres (made by cutting down a cardboard carton) sheet of glass, larger than 60 × 30 centimetres 6 metres of plastic tubing or garden hose 2-litre plastic bottle cardboard carton (big enough to hold the plastic bottle) thermometer scissors with pointed ends plasticine sticky tape water black and white poster paints sheet of clear plastic, larger than 60 × 30 centimetres a variety of insulating materials (eg, old clothing, sawdust, plastic foam, crumpled newspapers)
Set up the model solar water heater (as shown in the diagram) and place it in a sunny position. Fill the bottle and the plastic tubing with water. Record the temperature of the water after the solar water heater has been in sunlight for 20 minutes. Test for the effect on the temperature of altering variables (eg, clear plastic versus glass covering the box; various insulating materials around the bottle; the colour of the bottom of the cardboard box; the angle at which the box is tilted). Questions
Teachers notes
ATSE Focus March/April 2004 Renewables to the rescue? Wind and solar energy in Australia (by Ian Grey) Looks at the capacity of Australia to meet its energy requirements using wind and solar power.
Australasian Science September 2006, pages 31-32 Photosynthetic photovoltaics (by Simon Grose) Profiles solar cell technology that is inspired by photosynthesis.
Cosmos 18 April 2007 Slicing the cost of solar power (by David Kay) Looks at a novel approach to make low cost photovoltaic cells.
Ecos No. 131, 2006, pages 12-14 Solar cities generating new approaches (by Hartley Henderson) Describes the Solar Cities program to trial the latest solar technology in cities across Australia.
No. 130, 2006, page 33 Roof tiles go solar (by Steve Davidson) Describes a roof tile that is a solar panel that provides both solar power and solar hot water to homes.
No. 129, 2006, page 4 Solar thermal power warms up Suggests that solar thermal energy is emerging as a cost-competitive source of electrical power.
No. 124, 2005, pages 28-30 A stirling idea (by Wendy Pyper) A new spin on the age-old technology of the Stirling engine could provide a cheap, portable, low maintenance renewable energy unit.
No. 124, 2005, page 27 Sun-power technology centre underway Covers the construction of the National Solar Energy Technology Centre at Newcastle, Australia.
No. 121, 2004, page 30 Reconciliation re-invigorates solar development (by Wendy Pyper) A new project aims to provide energy from renewable sources for the Yolngu people of Dhuruputjpi in Arnhem Land.
No. 117, 2003, pages 8-9 One golden pond (by Wendy Pyper) Describes a 'solar pond', which uses shallow ponds of saline water to harness solar energy.
No. 116, 2003, pages 10-12 Siphoning the sun (by Graeme O'Neill) Describes the kilometer-high solar tower project which could power 200,000 homes.
Nature 7 September 2006, pages 19-22 A new day dawning?: Silicon Valley sunrise (by Oliver Morton) Looks at interest in photovoltaic research in California's Silicon Valley.
New Scientist A collection of stories on energy and fuels is available.
8 December 2007, pages 32-37 Solar power: The future’s bright (by Bennett Daviss) Explores the future of power generation from solar energy.
24 November 2007, pages 42-45 Plugging into the sun (by Dan Cho and David Cohen) Investigates the potential of space solar power.
5 May 2007, page 15 High cost of capturing solar energy is diminishing (by Jim Giles) Looks at the potential of concentrated solar power as a source of energy.
9 December 2006, page 32 Cut-price solar panels follow the sun (by Duncan Graham-Rowe) Reports on a new solar panel that is designed to cut the cost of harnessing the sun’s energy.
11 November 2006, pages 30-31 Take a leaf out of nature's book to tap solar power (by Duncan Graham-Rowe) Looks at mimicking the process of photosynthesis to harness energy from sunlight more efficiently.
14 October 2006, pages 52-55 Hello solar (by Tim Thwaites) Tells the story of a solar powered ferry.
27 May 2006, pages 44-47 Two for the price of one (by Herb Brody) Explains how nano solar cells improve the efficiency of energy production from sunlight.
29 October 2005, page 28 Box of tricks takes surgery into the sticks (by Michael Day) Describes the solar powered 'hospital in a box' used to perform operations in remote locations.
18 December 2004 Pliable solar cells are on a roll (by Fred Pearce) Describes a light, flexible solar panel that is made in rolls and can be cut to any length.
17 July 2004 Is the green dream doomed to fail? (by Jenny Hogan and Philip Cohen) Questions the ability of renewable energy sources to replace fossil fuels without subsidies and incentives.
15 May 2004, page 16 Wring more might from your light A new semiconductor nanocrystal could convert 60 per cent of sunlight into useable power by releasing more electrons per photon.
Scientific American January 2008, pages 34-35 Sun power gets a boost (by Mark Alpert) Explores the incorporation of an artificial photosynthesis process in photovoltaic cell design.
December 16 2007, pages 48-57 A solar grand plan (by Ken Zweibel, James Mason and Vasilis Fthenakis) Presents a grand plan employing solar technology to provide the U.S. with power.
Concentrating Solar Thermal Systems (Solar Thermal Group, Australian National University)
Provides technical descriptions of some solar thermal collecting systems.
Tapping into the sun (National Renewable Energy Laboratory, USA)
An article on photovoltaic cells with case studies.
How Stuff Works, USA
Australian Government Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts
Map of operating renewable energy generators in Australia (Geoscience Australia)
Provides maps of proposed and operational renewable energy generators across Australia.
Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Revisiting solar power's past (Solarenergy.com)
A 10-page history of attempts to convert solar radiation into mechanical power. (An article by Charles Smith from Massachusetts Institute of Technology's Technology Review, July 1995.)
fossil fuels. Carbon or hydrocarbon fuels, derived from what was living material, and found underground or beneath the sea. The most common forms are coal, oil and natural gas. They take millions of years to form. Their energy is only released upon burning, when the carbon and hydrogen within them combine with the oxygen in air to form carbon dioxide (CO2 ), or carbon monoxide (CO) and water (H2O). Other elements within the fuels (such as sulfur or nitrogen) are also released into the air after combining with oxygen, causing further pollution with SO2 and nitrogen oxide gases. In the case of coal, ash particles are also a problem. non-renewable energy. Used to describe energy sources that exist in a limited amount on Earth. Thus all available material could eventually be completely used up. Coal, oil and gas (see fossil fuels) are considered as non-renewable energy sources because the rate of their formation is so slow on human timescales that they we are using them without them being replaced. Uranium (used in nuclear power) is also non-renewable, although its reserves are very large compared to its rate of use. Compare renewable energy. passive solar heating. The use of the sun to heat buildings. Careful design and positioning of buildings can ensure that sunlight in the winter months will warm them by day, with much of the warmth remaining during the night. Summer sunlight is usually kept out. This does not involve the conversion or harnessing of solar energy. photovoltaic (PV) cells. Also known as solar cells. A photovoltaic cell is made of thin wafers of two slightly different types of silicon. One, doped with tiny quantities of boron, is called P-type (P for positive) and contains positively charged 'holes', which are missing electrons. (Electrons are negatively charged particles that orbit the nuclei of atoms.) The other type of silicon is doped with small amounts of phosphorus and is called N-type (N for negative). It contains extra electrons. Putting these two thin P and N materials together produces a junction which, when exposed to light, will produce a movement of electrons and that constitutes an electric current. Photovoltaic cells thus convert light energy into electrical energy. renewable energy. Used to describe energy sources that are replenished by natural processes on a sufficiently rapid time-scale so that they can be used by humans more or less indefinitely, provided the quantity taken per unit of time is not too great. Examples are animal dung, ethanol (derived from plant sugars), wood, wind, falling water and sunlight. Compare non-renewable. For more information see Renewable energy (Australian Greenhouse Office). solar collectors. Devices for capturing the sun’s energy over a large area and focussing it on a small area, thereby concentrating it. In this way it can be made to provide extremely high temperatures, used to generate steam that will expand, or to carry out a chemical reaction to produce a portable fuel such as hydrogen. Solar collectors may be curved dishes - like satellite receiving dishes coated with reflective material, or can consist of an array of reflectors, arranged like flower petals, focussing onto a central point. Usually the dish or the individual reflectors can be steered to follow the sun across the sky. solar energy. Energy derived ultimately from the sun. It can be divided into direct and indirect categories. Most energy sources on Earth are forms of indirect solar energy, although we usually don’t think of them in that way. Coal, oil and natural gas derive from ancient biological material which took its energy from the sun (via plant photosynthesis) millions of years ago. All the energy in wood and foodstuffs also comes from the sun. Movement of the wind (which causes waves at sea), and the evaporation of water to form rainfall which accumulates in rivers and lakes, are also powered by the sun. Therefore, hydroelectric power and wind and wave power are forms of indirect solar energy. Direct solar energy is what we usually mean when we speak of solar power it is the use of sunlight for heating or generating electricity.
External sites are not endorsed by the Australian Academy of Science. Posted February 1997. The Australian Foundation for Science is also a supporter of Nova.
This topic is sponsored by the Australian Government's National Innovation Awareness Strategy.
|