Nova: Science in the news
Published by the Australian Academy of Science
Back to the normal view

Enhanced greenhouse effect – a hot international topic


The meeting on greenhouse gas emissions held in Kyoto in December 1997 put the enhanced greenhouse effect in the spotlight.
Contents

Key text

Box 1. Greenhouse gases
Box 2. What is modelling?
Box 3. Global warming and climate change
Box 4. International deliberations
Box 5. Australia's policy response
Activities Activity 1. Temperature increases in a mini-greenhouse
Activity 2. Data on carbon dioxide emissions
Activity 3. Reducing greenhouse gas emissions
Further reading
Useful sites
Glossary

Key text

Without the greenhouse effect we would be living in a very chilly place – the world's average temperature would be minus 18°C, instead of the 16°C we are used to. So what is the greenhouse effect and how does it make Earth around 34°C warmer?

The natural greenhouse effect

The natural greenhouse effect is a phenomenon created by the heat energy radiated by the sun and greenhouse gases normally present in the atmosphere. In simple terms, sunlight passes through the atmosphere, warming the Earth. In turn, the Earth radiates this energy back towards space. As it passes through the atmosphere, greenhouse gases (water vapour, carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide) absorb part of the energy, while the remainder escapes into space. This means that some of the sun's energy becomes trapped – thus making the lower part of the atmosphere, and Earth, warmer.

Energy in balance

If the atmosphere accumulated all the trapped heat, then the Earth's temperature would just rise and rise, but it doesn't. The temperature only rises until the amount of infrared or long wave radiation leaving the Earth balances the amount of energy coming in from the sun. As long as the amount of greenhouse gases in the air stays the same, and as long as the amount of heat arriving from the sun is constant, an equilibrium is established. This is a steady state where as much energy is lost to space as is gained from the sun. In equilibrium, the natural greenhouse effect maintains the average temperature of Earth at 16°C.

The atmosphere is changing

The Earth's atmosphere is made up of 78 per cent nitrogen and 21 per cent oxygen. Only about 1 per cent is made up of natural greenhouse gases, but this comparatively small amount of gas makes a big difference. Before the Industrial Revolution (which started in England about 200 years ago) the mix of gases that made up the atmosphere was relatively constant. The Industrial Revolution brought new industrial processes, more extensive agriculture, and a rapid increase in the world's population. This rapid increase in human activity meant that more of the gases which cause the greenhouse effect were released into the atmosphere. We know this because of measurements made over the last 35 years and the analysis of air bubbles trapped in ancient ice. There is now clear evidence that levels of carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide and halocarbons are increasing (Box 1: Greenhouse gases).

The enhanced greenhouse effect and climate change

Many scientists think that the increasing concentrations of these greenhouse gases will lead to an increase in the world's average temperature. This is called the enhanced greenhouse effect.

While scientists agree that the levels of greenhouse gases are rising, there is less certainty about what the precise effects of this will be. To help them understand these effects, scientists use mathematical models (Box 2: What is modelling?). These models take account of many processes that together determine the behaviour of the atmosphere (eg, temperature, humidity, wind speed and atmospheric pressure). Many researchers are predicting that the world will get warmer, but exactly how much warmer or how quickly it will happen is still being debated (Box 3: Global warming and climate change).

A national and international issue

An increase in global temperature would bring changes to the entire planet, and therefore to every nation. This makes it an international issue which needs worldwide study and responses (Box 4: International deliberations). But individual countries are each responsible for their own greenhouse gas production. Australia produces about 1.5 per cent of the world's anthropogenic greenhouse gases. We have very high emissions of greenhouse gases relative to other developed countries, considering the size of our population and economy (Box 5: Australia's policy response). One of the reasons for this is that other nations have reduced their carbon dioxide emissions because they use more natural gas and nuclear power instead of oil and coal.

Australia and over 150 other countries signed the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change at the first Earth Summit held in Rio de Janeiro in 1992. This agreement set up a process which enabled governments to meet regularly to discuss action to avert extreme climate change. As a result of subsequent talks, all developed countries were asked to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions to 1990 levels. In December 1997, a conference of governments held in Japan attempted to reach legally binding agreements about what each country should do. The idea was for each country to reduce its greenhouse gas output by a similar percentage.

The Australian government argued that this was not fair on Australia because we have a different sort of economy from some other developed nations, and would suffer economic and social costs if we reduced our emissions by the same percentage as other countries. But if we used nuclear power or more natural gas or more renewable energy sources such as solar power then we wouldn't need to create so much carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases.

There was also some dispute about the accuracy of the mathematical model used to calculate the effect of reducing our greenhouse gases. This is important because the government's argument was partly based on the predictions of this model.

Australian scientists

Australian scientists are working on many aspects of the greenhouse effect. Some scientists try to determine climatic trends. Others model the effect of the enhanced greenhouse effect on Australia's climate and economy. Still others live and work on the Antarctic ice cap, to see what effect the enhanced greenhouse effect may be having there. All this is part of a worldwide attempt to better understand what may be causing global warming and to decide what can be done about it.

Related Nova topics:

Impact of global warming on biodiversity

Predicting natural events

Warmer and sicker? Global warming and human health

Getting into hot water – global warming and rising sea levels

Coral bleaching – will global warming kill the reefs?

Carbon currency – the credits and debits of carbon emissions trading

The Southern Ocean and global climate


Box 1. Greenhouse gases

Scientists have been regularly measuring the air's carbon dioxide (CO2) content since about 1960. Several stations around the world monitor this and the concentrations of the other greenhouse gases.

But how can we find out the CO2 concentrations that existed before this regular monitoring started? Evidence comes from a variety of sources, but one of the most straightforward involves taking ice samples from the polar ice caps. Ice in Antarctica builds up from the compression of each year's snowfalls. By drilling down into the ice cap (which is up to 4 kilometres thick), scientists can collect core samples of the annual snowfall going back over thousands of years. The deeper you go, the older the ice.

This ice contains air bubbles, captured when the snow fell and sealed in ice since that time. Scientists can take a slice of a core and analyse the air trapped within the bubbles. This ice record can give us information about the air from as far back as 740,000 years ago. The ice record shows that for many thousands of years the CO2 concentration slowly fluctuated. It remained steady during the last few thousand years, but began to increase about the year 1800 – as did methane and nitrous oxide. (Human activity has caused no significant direct increase in water vapour.)

Human activity causes increases in greenhouse gases

Carbon dioxide

The increase in CO2 is partly caused by fossil-fuel burning, cement manufacture, land clearing, forest harvesting and changes in agricultural practice. According to the National Greenhouse Gas Inventory of 2005, CO2 accounts for 74.3 per cent of Australia's greenhouse gas emissions.

Methane

Biomass burning, increased agricultural production in rice paddy fields, digestive fermentation (burps and farts) from cattle and other livestock, and leaks from natural gas pipelines and coal mines have lead to a steady increase in methane emissions. Methane production accounts for 20.2 per cent of Australia's greenhouse gas emissions.

Nitrous oxide

There are many small sources of this gas both natural and manufactured that are difficult to quantify. The main sources created by human activity are from agriculture (especially the development of pastures in tropical regions), biomass burning and number of industrial processes. Nitrous oxide production accounts for 4.3 per cent of Australia's greenhouse gas emissions.

Halocarbons

Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) are halocarbons which were widely used for propellants, refrigerants, and foaming agents. Their use rapidly increased after their invention in the 1930s. The realisation that they were responsible for ozone depletion in the stratosphere has led to their phasing out under the 1987 Montreal Protocol. Perfluorocarbons, another type of halocarbon, are produced during aluminium production. Halocarbon production accounts for 1.1 per cent of Australia's greenhouse gas emissions. (Despite their small concentrations, halocarbons have a significant greenhouse effect.)

Related site


Box 2. What is modelling?

Modelling is a way of simplifying the real world to enable us to solve problems. We do it all the time and so easily that we don’t even notice we are doing it. For example, a street directory is a model of a city’s roads, a diagram is a model of how something is made, and even a calendar is a model of a month. People use these models to solve problems, such as ‘What is the shortest route?’, ‘How do I put this together?’, ‘How long until my birthday?’.

Mathematics is one of the most important modelling tools. The ancient Egyptians used geometry to model and divide up their farmland. In the 1600s, Isaac Newton developed calculus, a way of mathematically describing moving objects. He used equations to accurately model the motion of the planets – one of the greatest scientific achievements. Today we use sophisticated computer models in many ways; for example, to help predict the weather, simulate climate change, and assess the impact of population on the environment.

How does modelling work?

Modelling is a five-step process. A simple way to see how the steps work is to imagine that you have been asked to organise a function for 30 people. Your problem is to decide how much to charge each person to cover all the costs.

Step 1. Get a clear picture of the problem.
Decide what things have to be bought or hired for the function.

Step 2. Choose the most appropriate mathematics to solve the problem and then present the problem in mathematical language.
In this case you would choose estimation, addition and division.

Step 3. Solve the mathematical problem.
Estimate how much a typical person would eat and drink and work out the costs involved. Add them all up and divide by 30 – the number of people coming to the function.

Step 4. Translate your answer back into the language of the original problem.
The amount, in dollars, you would need to charge each person.

Step 5. Check the solution your mathematics has produced. Is it a good enough answer for your needs?
The amount you charge each person should be affordable and comparable with charges for similar functions.

What makes a good model?

The aim of a model is to simplify the problem. Using a street directory to find your way around a city is much easier than using trial and error or just heading off in one direction. However you usually have to reach a balance between simplicity and accuracy. Seasons give us a simple model for general weather patterns – hot or cold, wet or dry. But the model may not be accurate on any particular day.

Good models must include the most significant factors and describe the most important features of a problem but may omit factors of minor importance. You would expect that temperature measurements might be important for a weather model, and the model should tell you if it will rain or not. But the cost of potato chips is not a factor that should be in a model about weather!

Finally, a good model must be accurate enough to make predictions. Your costing of the function is not very useful if no-one could afford to come. Similarly, if a weather model predicts warm sunshine but it snows instead, then the model should be checked.

Modelling is important for solving problems, we do it all the time. But there are always more problems, and more ways of making models – great challenges still remain.

Related sites


Box 3. Global warming and climate change

An average global temperature rise of just 0.2 to 0.3°C per decade over the next hundred years could have severe consequences, because some regions will experience a much higher than average increase. Even a slight average temperature change can affect the weather in particular regions. The El Nino Southern Oscillation is a good example of how a comparatively slight change in one place can lead to major droughts or floods in another. Climatic zones would be expected to shift – meaning that areas currently too cold for crop growing might develop a warmer summer and a longer growing season. Countries such as Russia and Canada which have extensive areas with permanently frozen soil, might benefit by being able to use these for agriculture.

But rainfall patterns could also change, making some currently viable crop-growing areas hotter and drier until they degenerate into desert. On the other hand, if certain ocean currents change direction then some regions could actually become colder. Other changes could affect the oceans even more drastically.

Whether or not natural ecosystems could adapt readily remains to be seen. Perhaps some could, but certain species, tolerant of only a narrow band of temperature and unable to move their range fast enough, could become extinct.

Predicting the future is difficult

While the basic physics of the greenhouse effect is well understood, predicting the future course of events is made difficult because of our insufficient knowledge about the detailed behaviours of the atmosphere and oceans. There are at least five areas of incomplete understanding:

  • sources (places of origin) and sinks (places of storage) of greenhouse gases – which affect predictions of future concentrations;

  • clouds – which strongly influence the magnitude of climate change;

  • oceans – which influence the timing and patterns of climate change;

  • polar ice-sheets – which affect the predictions of sea-level rise;

  • land surface processes and feedback (when the output of a system affects the input) – which affect hydrological and ecological processes.

There are also limitations to the computer models which are used to simulate an Earth-atmosphere system.

Related sites


Box 4. International deliberations

The prospect of an enhanced greenhouse effect has generated plenty of heat between national governments. The development of international policies to address greenhouse – and the responses of governments to these policies – is a fascinating subject in its own right.

In the 1980s the World Meteorological Organization and the United Nations Environment Programme established an international panel of government representatives and scientists to review the science of climate change. Known as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), it has published numerous extensive reports that have become the source for much of the material used in discussions and decision-making about the enhanced greenhouse effect.

At the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, Australia and about 150 other countries signed the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. Australia ratified the convention in December 1992. As a party to the convention, Australia must report its greenhouse gas emissions and the strategies and measures it has adopted to reduce them.

The stated objective of the Framework Convention is to achieve

...stabilisation of the greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that would prevent dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system. Such a level should be achieved within a time-frame sufficient to allow ecosystems to adapt naturally to climate change, to ensure that food production is not threatened and to enable economic development to proceed in a sustainable manner.

The countries party to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change met in Berlin in early 1995 in what is known as the first meeting of the Conference of the Parties (COP1). They agreed to continue cooperating internationally on the enhanced greenhouse effect. But there was little agreement on what measures could be implemented. After much negotiation, delegates started work on a protocol.

COP2 was held in July 1996 in Geneva. There, the countries agreed that talks on reducing greenhouse gas emissions should be accelerated.

Earth Summit II in New York in June 1997 reviewed how successfully Earth Summit I commitments had been implemented in the 5 years since they were agreed to. Australia’s opposition to legally binding, uniform targets on greenhouse gas emissions received international criticism. The Australian Government argued that all nations start at a different base with respect to greenhouse gases. For example, some countries have copious supplies of hydroelectricity, others depend on inputs of energy-intensive methods, still others have economies that are less energy dependent. Within the European Union differential targets were allowed for these and other reasons. Thus, in this regard, Australia's approach was not that different.

COP3 took place in Kyoto, Japan in December 1997, resulting in the Kyoto Protocol. This agreement sets the collective global target of reducing greenhouse gas emissions by about 5 per cent of 1990 levels by 2012. Australia, which argued that it was a special case because of increasing population, dependence on fossil fuels and a decentralised economy, had its target set at 8 per cent above 1990 levels.

COP4 took place in Buenos Aires, Argentina in November 1998, where a 2-year plan of action was adopted to reduce the risk of global climate change.

COP5 was held in Bonn, Germany in October/November 1999. Progress was made on the following issues: accelerating the negotiation process; Kyoto mechanisms; land-use, land use change and forestry; and compliance. In November 2000, negotiations were suspended at COP6 when no agreement was reached on rules to make the Kyoto Protocol operational.

COP6 resumed in July 2001 in Bonn, Germany. Although the United States was not part of the talks, other industrialised nations reached partial agreement about how to begin addressing the problem of climate change.

At COP7, held in Marrakesh, Morocco in November 2001, extended discussions produced a rule book for the Kyoto Protocol, clearing the way for ratification.

COP 8 was held in Delhi, India in October 2002, where participants urged that the Kyoto Protocol be brought into force as quickly as possible, and agreed on procedural rules related to documentation and reporting of emissions. Discussions on the obligations of developing countries to meet emissions targets were heated.

At COP 9, held in Milan, Italy in December 2003, there was a call for Russia to ratify the protocol, discussion about technicalities relating to carbon sinks and the formation of two funds to assist developing countries.

COP 10 was held in Buenos Aires, Argentina in December 2004, and focused on preparation for the implementation of the Kyoto Protocol, after Russia agreed to ratify the protocol. There was discussion about bringing existing policies into force and the next phase of negotiations, without any new commitments being made beyond 2012.

The Kyoto Protocol came into force on 16 February 2005. The attention of advocates of the protocol has now turned to strengthening the agreement for the years following the initial commitment period of 2008 to 2012. One of the challenges is to include all of the major emitting countries, both developed and developing. Another is to begin significant long term reductions in carbon emissions to prevent further climate change.

COP 11 took place in Montreal, Canada in November/December 2005. Participants discussed and adopted decisions on a number of operational details of the Kyoto Protocol. Participants of the event also agreed on a process for considering actions beyond 2012 under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.

COP 12 was held in Nairobi, Kenya in November 2006. This conference was the first of such gatherings in sub-Saharan Africa, with business and economic issues taking on a prominent role in the discussions. However little progress was made at the event towards the new agreements beyond 2012, when the existing Kyoto commitments expire.

Related site


Box 5. Australia's policy response

Australia began addressing the enhanced greenhouse effect and its consequences in a formal way through the National Greenhouse Response Strategy, which was endorsed in 1992.

The National Greenhouse Response Strategy was replaced in late 1996 by the National Greenhouse Strategy. It is the primary mechanism through which our international commitments will be met.

Under this strategy, a number of programs have been launched or continued. For example, the Greenhouse Challenge Plus, launched in March 2005, is a cooperative effort between Australian industry and the Commonwealth Government to reduce greenhouse emissions through voluntary industry action. Around 780 Australian companies are part of the program. Another scheme allows carbon 'pooling' so that growers of small forests can group together to participate in abatement programs.

Australia signed the Kyoto Protocol in 1998, but the agreement was not ratified until December 2007.

In 2005, the National Greenhouse Gas Inventory – the annual statistical report on greenhouse gas emissions – stated that Australia had achieved 102.2 per cent increase in emissions and is on course to meet the emissions target of 108 per cent. While this is an increase in emissions, if business had continued 'as usual' the emissions would be 125 per cent of 1990 levels by 2008-2012. The difference between what has been achieved and what would have occurred without change in policy is equivalent to removing every car in Australia from the road.

The response of the New South Wales and Australian Capital Territory governments

About half of Australia's carbon emissions come from coal-fired electricity generating stations. Unlike many countries, we do not have nuclear power stations or large hydro schemes to produce electricity. In Australia, NSW and the ACT are the only states to have mandatory Greenhouse Gas Abatement Schemes. The NSW scheme was introduced in January 2003 and the ACT scheme in January 2005. Both schemes are interlinked and involve cooperation between the states. Electricity retailers must now meet mandatory targets for reducing the emission of greenhouse gases from the production of the electricity they supply or use.

The NSW and ACT targets for emissions are 7.27 and 7.97 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent per capita by 2007. This target is 5 per cent below the level determined in the Kyoto Protocol baseline year of 1990. The target levels will be maintained until at least 2012. If participants fail to meet targets, they will pay a penalty per tonne of emissions above their targets.

Abatement certificates are issued by accredited organisations for low-emission generation of electricity, reduced consumption of electricity and capture of carbon from the atmosphere by forests. Each certificate is equivalent to 1 tonne of CO2 equivalent associated with the consumption of electricity.

Related sites


Activities

  • Australian Government Bureau of Meteorology
    • Climate change – students investigate natural and human activities that cause climate change.

  • Metro magazine (Australia)

  • Project AIRE (United States Environmental Protection Agency, New England)

  • Science upd8 (UK)
    You need to register to access activities but they are free.

  • Classroom of the Future (NASA, USA)
    • Fossil fuel burning – students compare the CO2 released by fossil fuel burning to the actual increase in atmospheric CO2.

  • Xpeditions (National Geographic, USA)

  • New York Times Learning Network (USA)
    • Clearing the air – students investigate emissions that contribute to global warming, and present to a mock international summit recommendations for reversing the global warming trend.
    • Ice breakers – students demonstrate several physical properties of ice, then relate these properties to the effects of global warming on icecaps.
    • Walking on thin ice? – students examine scientific evidence of changes in the Arctic ice cover.
    • Weathering the weather – students explore the effects of global warming on their community.
    • Tending to the greenhouse – students examine global warming – its causes, effects and solutions.

  • University of Buffalo (USA)

  • Global warming: Early warning signs (USA)

  • Check out the Activities at our topic on carbon emissions trading.


Activity 1. Temperature increases in a mini-greenhouse

Materials (for the class)

  • 3 identical containers (eg, shoeboxes or 4-litre ice-cream containers)
  • scissors
  • sheet of clear plastic (approximately 15 centimetres × 15 centimetres)
  • sheet of glass (approximately 15 centimetres × 15 centimetres)
  • thermometer
  • plasticine

Procedure

  1. Cut out a large rectangle or square from the lid of each container.

  2. Use sticky tape to fix a sheet of clear plastic over the opening in the lid of the first container.

  3. Put a sheet of glass over the second container and leave the third one open.

  4. Make a small hole through which a thermometer can be inserted in one side of each container.

  5. Leave the containers in sunlight and record the temperature inside each container every 5 minutes for 20 minutes. (You can plug the hole for the thermometer with plasticine when you are not measuring the temperature.)

  6. Graph the results and write a few lines about what you conclude from your results.

Teachers notes

If you have three thermometers, you can leave a thermometer in each box and record the three temperatures at 5-minute intervals. A different version of this activity can be found in Investigating (Australian Primary and Junior Science Journal), August 1997, pages 6-7.


Activity 2. Data on carbon dioxide emissions

The following graph shows carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from various sectors of the community for five OECD countries in 1992.

Graph

  1. Which of the five countries produces the greatest percentage of its CO2 emissions from:
    1. industry;
    2. transport;
    3. agriculture;
    4. providing services;
    5. households?

  2. Which country produces the lowest percentage of its CO2 emissions from industry?

  3. In which sector(s) should Australia try to reduce CO2 emissions?

  4. Much of the electricity consumed by Australian industry is used for processing metals (eg, we turn bauxite (an ore) into pure aluminium metal, which we export).
    1. If we exported the raw bauxite, what effect would this have on our CO2 emissions?
    2. How is Australia advantaged by processing bauxite before it is exported; how is it disadvantaged?


Activity 3. Reducing greenhouse gas emissions

How the problem of the enhanced greenhouse effect is being approached by the Australian government is important to us all.

Working in groups of two or three, discuss the issues raised by the following questions and make brief notes of your views.

  • Should we be taking action now to cut down on emissions of greenhouse gases, or should we wait until the full extent of global warming and climate change are known?

  • What effects would reducing greenhouse gas emissions be likely to have on Australia's economy and on our standard of living?

  • Is Australia a major contributor to the world's greenhouse gas emissions?


Further reading


ATSE Focus
March 2006
Energy options and greenhouse consequences (by Peter Cook)
Looks at the options available for carbon capture and storage.


Australasian Science
June 2007, page 15
Climate change report presents options for action
Summarises the findings of the latest United Nations IPCC report.


May 2007, page 11
Greenhouse gases make WA drier
Reports that half of the reduction in rainfall in south-west Western Australia over the past 40 years is the result of human-induced global warming.


Australian Antarctic Magazine
Spring 2005, pages 2-4
Climate change: Cold, hard facts on a hot topic (by Tas van Ommen)
Discusses aspects of climate change, with an emphasis on Antarctic issues.


Cosmos
Jun/Jul 2007, page 10
Massive ancient volcanoes caused global warming
Reports on evidence linking global warming to volcanic activity 55 million years ago.


Economist
31 May 2007
A stairway to heaven?
Explores the potential of the Earth’s magnetic field as a conveyor belt to get rid of carbon dioxide.


Ecos
No. 132, 2006, pages 8-11
Fossilised giant clams give high fidelity climate records (by Wendy Pyper)
Ancient giant clams dug from Papua New Guinea's tropical rainforests provide a unique and detailed record of climate 400 000 years ago, and may help answer some of today's central climate change questions.


No. 124, 2005, pages 4-5
Greenhouse gas levels in reach with action and new technology
Suggests that Australia can stabilize its emissions within ten years using current technologies.


No. 123, 2005, pages 15-17
Air transport impacts take off (by Steve Davidson)
Discusses the growth of the aviation industry and the need for controls on emissions.


The Helix
October-November 2005, pages 14-17
Climate science hots up (by Sarah Tennet)
Explains how scientists measure CO2 levels in the past using ice cores.


Nature
A collection of articles about climate change is available.


New Scientist
A collection of New Scientist articles on climate change is available.


2 March 2008, pages 14-15
No time to lose in cutting CO2 emissions (by Jim Giles)
Discusses the impacts of delaying greenhouse gas emission cuts.


27 October 2007, page 42-46
CO2: Don’t count on the trees (by Douglas Fox)
Explores the ability of trees to absorb CO2 from the atmosphere.


16 August 2007, page 11
Climate tipping points loom large (by Fred Pearce)
Looks into predictions of climate models.


20 June 2007, pages 16-19
Exclusive global warming poll: the buck stops here (by Peter Aldous)
Examines the results from a global warming poll.


19 May 2007, pages 34-42
The 7 biggest myths about climate change (by Catherine Brahic, David Chandler, Michael Le Page, Phil McKenna, Fred Pearce)
Discusses the myths and misconceptions about the planet’s climate.


24 March 2007, pages 16-17
What’s behind the big polar meltdown? (by Catherine Brahic)
Looks at possible mechanisms to explain the melting behaviour of glaciers.


21 March 2007
Movies map global greenhouse gas movement (by Fred Pearce)
Movies of accumulated satellite data reveal how concentrations of key human-made greenhouse gases change with the seasons.


12 February 2007
CO2 being pushed deep into the oceans (by Catherine Brahic)
Explains the good and bad news about CO2 uptake by oceans.


2 December 2006, page 9
Climate change sceptics lose vital argument (by Zeeya Merali)
Looks at recent evidence to explain why the 'little ice age' does not register on the hockey stick graph.


11 November 2006, page 8
The poor will pay for global warming (by Fred Pearce)
Looks at human rights issues relevant to climate change.


4 November 2006, pages 18-21
State of denial (by Fred Pearce)
Looks at the deepening divide between IPCC scientists and sceptics over global warming.


30 September 2006, pages 8-9
'One degree and we're done for' (by Fred Pearce)
Warns that sub-Arctic forests and bogs may be just 1oC away from a disastrous and unstoppable thaw.


14 September 2006
Winter Arctic sea ice in drastic decline (by Phil McKenna)
Reports that Arctic ice cover is now shrinking in the winter as well as the summer.


16 September 2006, pages 32-36
Global warming: Will the Sun come to our rescue? (by Stuart Clark)
Looks at the affect of the Sun’s activity cycles on global warming.


19 August 2006, pages 8-9
Glaciers heading for point of no return (by Jessica Marshall)
Suggests that if Greenland's ice carries on melting at the same rate, it could reach a critical threshold by the century's end.


5 August 2006, pages 28-33
Ocean acidification: the other CO2 problem (by Caspar Henderson)
Describes the problem of ocean acidification associated with increasing atmospheric CO2.


24 March 2006
Glacial earthquakes rock Greenland ice sheet (by Jeff Hecht)
Reports on an increase in the number of glacial earthquakes caused by sudden shifts in glaciers due to rapid melting.


27 May 2006, pages 8-9
Let the Supreme Court decide (by Jessica Marshall)
Discusses the possibility of the case Massachusetts versus Environmental Protection Agency appearing before the Supreme Court.


18 March 2006, pages 40-43
Grudge match (by Fred Pearce)
Discusses the validity of the hockey stick graph of world temperatures.


18 February 2006, page 10
If we don’t stop burning oil… (by Fred Pearce)
Looks at the potential impact of burning all available fossil fuels by the year 2100.


25 January 2006
2005 was the warmest year on record (by Shaoni Bhattacharya)
Reports that 2005 was the warmest year recorded so far.


3 December 2005, pages 6-7
Faltering currents trigger freeze fear (by Fred Pearce)
Describes research suggesting that the ocean current that warms western Europe is slowing.


3 December 2005, pages 36-41
The gathering storm (by Fred Pearce)
Reports on the controversy over whether global warming is making hurricanes stronger.


8 October 2005, page 12
Artic ice shrinking as it feels the heat (by Fred Pearce)
Shows the effect of global warming on ice cover in the Arctic Ocean.


10 September 2005, pages 36-40
Your planet needs you (by Dave Reay)
Presents 10 things that individuals can do to decrease greenhouse gas emissions.


3 September 2005, page 30
The big clean-up (by Ben Crystall)
Describes the Asia-Pacific Partnership on Clean Development and Climate which relies on technology to reduce greenhouse emissions.


RTD Info
February 2006
Mysteries of the ocean
Looks at the role of water on the Earth’s surface in global warming. Includes:
  • What is happening in the North Atlantic?
  • The unique relationship between the sea and CO2
  • The strange world of oceanic methane


May 2005, pages 7-10
The poles, archives of the world's climate
Looks at polar research into global warming. Includes:
  • Ice coring: a special selection
  • Thermophilic bacteria in Lake Vostok
  • The greenhouse phenomenon and climatic feedback


May 2005, pages 11-18
The polar regions: Sentinels of major climate change
A seven page special on the poles and global warming. Includes:
  • Polar flora and fauna facing up to major climate warming
  • The peoples of the Arctic, the first victims of global warming
  • And what would happen if the Gulf Stream stopped?
  • Ozone story
  • Satellites at the service of polar research
  • Permanent monitoring of the atmosphere from the Svalbard

Science
1 July 2005, page 100
How hot will the greenhouse world be? (by Richard Kerr)
Looks at the use of models to indicate possible scenarios for global warming.


Scientific American
August 2007, pages 48-57
The physical science behind climate change (by William Collins, Robert Colman, James Haywood, Martin Manning and Philip Mote)
Discusses scientific evidence behind climate change.


April 2007, pages 10-11
Conservative climate (by David Biello)
Says that the IPCC report may underestimate the climate change problem.


1 February 2007
Climate change science moves from proof to prevention (by David Biello)
Suggests that 2006 may trigger a change from looking at the causes of global warming to trying to prevent it.


21 November 2006
Mysterious stabilization of atmospheric methane may buy time in race to stop global warming
Reports that levels of methane in the atmosphere have stopped increasing.


October 2006
Fiddling while the planet burns (by Jeffrey Sachs)
Urges the Wall Street Journal's editorial writers to accept a challenge to learn about the science of global climate change.


28 September 2006
Rare mineral further implicates CO2 in last global warming (by JR Minkel)
Looks at ancient mineral deposits to answer questions about the effect of rising CO2 concentrations.


13 September 2006
No sunshine for global warming skeptics (by J R Minkel)
Provides evidence that the Sun’s energy output cannot explain recent global warming.


24 July 2006
Ask the experts
Answers the questions, ‘If carbon dioxide makes up only a minute portion of the atmosphere, how can global warming be traced to it? And how can such a tiny amount of change produce such large effects?’


Useful sites

The Australian Greenhouse Office (Commonwealth Government)

This site provides a range of information. For example, click on 'Emissions monitoring' for information about climate change and emissions projections and click on 'Government' for links to Australian initiatives to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
http://www.greenhouse.gov.au/


The greenhouse effect (CSIRO Atmospheric Research, Australia)

Provides information about the major greenhouse gases and their likely affect on global climate.
http://www.cmar.csiro.au/e-print/open/holper_2001b.html


Introduction to global warming (Encyclopedia of the Atmospheric Environment, UK)

A general explanation of the causes and consequences of global warming. Highlighted words link to more detailed articles on specific topics.
http://www.ace.mmu.ac.uk/eae/Global_Warming/Older/Global_Warming_Introduction.html


Maps and graphics (United Nations Environment Progamme GRID Arendal)

Provides a wide range of graphics showing the impact of climate change, including changes to temperature, rainfall and crop production, as well as the impact on natural disasters, sea level, disease and wildlife.
http://maps.grida.no/go/searchFree/q/climate


Understanding climate change: A beginner's guide to the UN Framework Convention (Information Unit for Conventions, United Nations Environment Programme)

Addresses a few questions relating to climate change.
http://unfccc.int/resource/beginner.html


Global climate change (BBC News, UK)

As well as recent news items about climate change, this site provides background information on 'What is global warming?' and 'The politics of climate change'.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/sci_tech/2000/climate_change/default.stm


Royal Society, UK

  • Facts and fictions about climate change
    Examines twelve arguments put forward by opponents of urgent action on climate change, using scientific evidence to identify flaws in the arguments.
    http://www.royalsociety.org/page.asp?id=4761

  • Climate change – in my view
    Five members of the Royal Society present their views on climate change.
    http://www.royalsoc.ac.uk/page.asp?id=4607


Greenhouse Gas Online (UK)

Provides links to current news items about different aspects of the enhanced greenhouse effect.
http://www.ghgonline.org


Climate change: Observations and predictions (Hadley Centre for Climate Prediction and Research, UK)

This report attempts to answer three important questions: Is the climate changing? What has caused the climate to change? And how much do we expect the climate to change in future?
http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/hadleycentre/pubs/brochures/COP9.pdf


Global climate change: Research explorer (Exploratorium, USA)

Provides information about the physical processes underlying our climate and the kinds of data needed to determine how the climate is changing. This primer is organised into four interconnected sections – the atmosphere, the hydrosphere, the cryosphere and the biosphere.
http://www.exploratorium.edu/climate/index.html


Earth's fidgeting climate (Science@NASA, USA)

Discusses the difficulties in trying to determine whether climate change is the result of human activity or natural variations.
http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2000/ast20oct_1.htm?list153136


Ask the experts (Scientific American, 24 July 2006)

Answers the questions, ‘If carbon dioxide makes up only a minute portion of the atmosphere, how can global warming be traced to it? And how can such a tiny amount of change produce such large effects?’
http://www.sciam.com/print_version.cfm?articleID=000F22D3-EBEF-14C0-AB7083414B7F4945


American Institute of Physics, USA

  • Timeline of milestones
    Provides a timeline of important dates in the discovery of global warming.
    http://www.aip.org/history/climate/timeline.htm

  • The discovery of global warming
    Follows the change in scientific thinking during the 20th century leading to the discovery of rapid climate change.
    http://www.aip.org/history/climate/


Climate change science: An update of current understanding and uncertainties (Australian Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering)

Summarises the outcomes of a 2002 workshop on post-1995 changes in the understanding of climate change science.
http://www.atse.org.au/index.php?sectionid=469


Australian Broadcasting Corporation

  • It's easy being greener (The Lab, 19 October 2006)
    Tells how to make a few simple changes to have a big impact on climate change.
    http://www.abc.net.au/science/features/greener/

  • Study clears sun of climate change (News in Science, 14 September 2006)
    Reports on a study that weakens claims that climate change is due to natural sunspot cycles.
    http://abc.net.au/science/news/stories/2006/1740858.htm

  • Extreme clouds hover above Antarctica (News in Science, 2 August 2006)
    Reports on the observation of rare cloud forms in Antarctica, possibly due to climate change in the stratosphere.
    http://abc.net.au/science/news/stories/s1703610.htm

  • The business of climate change (Background Briefing, 16 October 2005)
    http://www.abc.net.au/rn/talks/bbing/stories/s1480714.htm

  • Soil may belch out CO2 to warm planet (News in Science, 8 September 2005)
    http://www.abc.net.au/science/news/stories/s1455886.htm

  • Planet slayer: Prof. Schpinkee's greenhouse calculator
    Use Prof Schpinkee's greenhouse calculator to work out how much of an environmental pig you are, and how long you should live. Also supplies a 'science behind the answers' explanation to each question.
    http://www.abc.net.au/science/planetslayer/greenhouse_calc.htm

  • International climate taskforce (Earthbeat, 20 November 2004)
    Earthbeat looks at the business case for acting on climate change and forecasts a spike in global grain prices will force people into action.
    http://www.abc.net.au/rn/science/earth/stories/s1247176.htm

  • The tree totaller (Earthbeat, 5 June 2004)
    A new household greenhouse gas calculator aims to help plant more trees to soak up dangerous emissions.
    http://www.abc.net.au/rn/science/earth/stories/s1124875.htm

  • Crystal ball climate change (The Lab, 22 April 2004)
    A good summary of many of the consequences of global warming. Includes a list of links to other Australian Broadcasting Corporation articles on climate change.
    http://abc.net.au/science/features/climatechange

  • CSIRO and greenhouse (transcript from The Science Show, 13 December 2003)
    Discusses evidence showing that global warming is occurring.
    http://www.abc.net.au/rn/science/ss/stories/s1010328.htm

  • Global warming – yes or no? (transcript from The Science Show, 15 November 2003)
    Looks at the statistical analysis of past climate data that was used to provide evidence of global warming.
    http://www.abc.net.au/rn/science/ss/stories/s988398.htm


Glossary

anthropogenic. Caused or induced by humans; of human origin.

chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs). Organic compounds made up of atoms of chlorine, fluorine and carbon. They were commonly used as refrigerants in refrigerators and air conditioners, as blowing agents in foam plastics, and as cleaners for computer circuit boards. CFCs do not occur naturally – their increase in the atmosphere is entirely the result of human activity. Beginning in the 1940s there was a rapid increase in the rate of manufacture, and hence the escape, of CFCs. The realisation that they were responsible for ozone depletion in the stratosphere has led to their phasing out under the 1987 Montreal Protocol.

Conference of the Parties (COP). Comprises all countries that have ratified the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. COP is responsible for implementing the objectives of the Convention and has been meeting regularly since 1995. More information can be found at Conference of the Parties (COP) (United Nations Environment Programme).

El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO). A sporadic climatic phenomenon that occurs because of changes in the usual atmospheric pressure patterns and in the sea surface temperature in parts of the Pacific Ocean. The results include the substantial reduction of the normal upwelling off the Peruvian coast, failure of the anchovy fishery in the same area, excessive rain in western South America, and droughts in Australia and parts of Indonesia.

enhanced greenhouse effect. An increase in the natural process of the greenhouse effect, brought about by human activities, whereby greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, methane, chlorofluorocarbons and nitrous oxide are being released into the atmosphere at a far greater rate than would occur through natural processes and thus their concentrations are increasing. Also called anthropogenic greenhouse effect or climate change.

global warming. An increase in the average temperature of the Earth's surface. Global warming is one of the consequences of the enhanced greenhouse effect and will cause worldwide changes to climate patterns.

greenhouse effect. The trapping and build-up of heat in the lower atmosphere near a planet's surface. Some of the heat flowing back towards space from the Earth's surface is absorbed by water vapour, carbon dioxide, methane and other gases in the atmosphere. If the atmospheric concentrations of these gases rises, then theory predicts that the average temperature of the lower atmosphere will gradually increase. The greenhouse effect in part explains the temperature differences of Mars, Venus and Earth.

halocarbons. Compounds of carbon combined with one or more of the elements called halogens (fluorine, chlorine, bromine, iodine, and astatine). Halocarbons containing fluorine, chlorine and bromine contribute to ozone depletion and to the enhanced greenhouse effect.

Kyoto Protocol. The third session of the Conference of the Parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change took place in Kyoto, Japan in December 1997, resulting in the Kyoto Protocol. This working agreement of the signatories commits developed countries to reduce their collective emissions of six greenhouse gases by at least 5 per cent of 1990 levels by 2012. The Kyoto agreement became legally binding on 16 February 2005 when 132 signatory countries agreed to strive to decrease carbon dioxide emissions. More information can be found at the official The Kyoto Protocol site.

Montreal Protocol. An intergovernmental document signed by many countries in 1987 (and regularly revised) which established restrictions for the manufacture and use of ozone-depleting substances in an international effort to reduce ozone depletion. The text of the Protocol with the 1990 and 1992 amendments is available.


External sites are not endorsed by the Australian Academy of Science.
Posted September 1997.

The Australian Foundation for Science is also a supporter of Nova.

This topic is sponsored by BHP


© Australian Academy of Science